A particle falls from rest at the vertex of an inverted catenary. Prove that the particle will leave the curve when the path described is √3 times the vertical distance through which the particle has fallen.
10 marks · directive: Prove
The core of a good answer
Using s = c tan ψ, y = c sec ψ and ρ = c sec²ψ, energy gives v² = 2gc(sec ψ − 1); the reaction vanishes when cos ψ = 1/2, i.e. ψ = 60°, where the arc fallen is c√3 and the vertical drop is c, so s = √3 × height fallen.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
This is motion on a smooth curve on its outer (convex) side. The candidate combines conservation of energy with the normal equation of motion, finds where the normal reaction becomes zero, and then uses the intrinsic and Cartesian equations of the catenary to compare arc length with vertical drop.
Answer outline
Introduction
Take the catenary in the standard form with parameter c: s = c tan ψ, y = c sec ψ (y measured from the directrix), radius of curvature ρ = c sec²ψ, ψ being the angle the tangent makes with the horizontal. Inverting it puts the vertex at the top; the particle starts there from rest and moves on the outside.
Step 1: Speed after the particle has turned through ψ
- Vertical distance fallen: h = c sec ψ − c = c(sec ψ − 1)
- Energy: v² = 2gh = 2gc(sec ψ − 1)
Step 2: Normal equation
- On the convex side the inward normal points towards the centre of curvature (downward side of the curve)
- mg cos ψ − R = mv²/ρ, where R is the normal reaction
- R = mg cos ψ − m·2gc(sec ψ − 1)/(c sec²ψ) = mg[cos ψ − 2(sec ψ − 1)cos²ψ]
Step 3: Condition for leaving
- R = 0: cos ψ = 2(sec ψ − 1)cos²ψ
- Divide by cos ψ: 1 = 2(1 − cos ψ)
- cos ψ = 1/2, so ψ = 60° (π/3)
Step 4: Arc length versus vertical drop
- Arc from the vertex: s = c tan 60° = c√3
- Vertical drop: h = c(sec 60° − 1) = c(2 − 1) = c
- s/h = √3
Conclusion
The particle leaves the curve when the arc described equals √3 times the vertical distance fallen. Check: R is positive for ψ < 60° (at ψ = 0 it equals mg) and would be negative beyond, so the particle leaves exactly at ψ = 60°.
Examples and data to cite
- A closely related standard result: a particle sliding from rest at the top of a smooth sphere of radius a leaves it after falling a/3, where cos θ = 2/3.
- The catenary relations y² = s² + c² and y = c sec ψ give sec 60° = 2 consistently: y = 2c, s = c√3, and 4c² = 3c² + c².
Facts to remember
- Intrinsic equation of the catenary: s = c tan ψ; Cartesian: y = c cosh(x/c); also y = c sec ψ and y² = c² + s².
- Radius of curvature of the catenary: ρ = ds/dψ = c sec²ψ.
- On a smooth curve, energy gives v² = 2g × (vertical distance fallen) for a start from rest.
- A particle leaves a smooth surface when the normal reaction becomes zero.