(i) A battleship is steaming ahead with velocity u. A gun is mounted on the ship so as to point straight backwards and is set at an angle of elevation α. If v be the velocity of projection relative to the gun, show that the range is (2v/g) sin α (v cos α − u) and the angle for maximum range is cos⁻¹((u + √(u² + 8v²))/(4v)) where g stands for acceleration due to gravity.
10 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
The shot's ground velocity is (v cos α − u) backwards horizontally and v sin α vertically, so with time of flight 2v sin α/g the range is (2v/g) sin α (v cos α − u); setting dR/dα = 0 gives 2v cos²α − u cos α − v = 0, i.e. cos α = (u + √(u² + 8v²))/(4v).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question tests relative velocity in projectile motion: the shell's velocity relative to the ground is its velocity relative to the gun plus the ship's velocity. Then the range is maximised by ordinary calculus with the correct root chosen.
Answer outline
Introduction
Ship velocity u forward; gun points backward at elevation α; muzzle velocity v relative to the gun. Range is measured from the point of firing on the ground (sea) frame.
Step 1: Absolute velocity of the shot
- Horizontal (backward): v cos α − u
- Vertical: v sin α (the ship's velocity is horizontal)
Step 2: Time of flight and range
- Time to return to the level of projection: T = 2v sin α/g
- R = (v cos α − u)·T = (2v/g) sin α (v cos α − u)
Step 3: Maximise R with respect to α
- dR/dα = (2v/g)[cos α (v cos α − u) − v sin²α]
- = (2v/g)[v cos²α − u cos α − v(1 − cos²α)] = (2v/g)(2v cos²α − u cos α − v)
- dR/dα = 0: 2v cos²α − u cos α − v = 0
- cos α = (u ± √(u² + 8v²))/(4v)
Step 4: Choose the root
- √(u² + 8v²) > u, so the minus sign gives cos α < 0 (α obtuse), which is not an elevation in the backward direction
- Hence cos α = (u + √(u² + 8v²))/(4v)
- d²R/dα² < 0 there (R is zero at α = 0 and at cos α = u/v, and positive between), so it is a maximum
Conclusion
Range = (2v/g) sin α (v cos α − u), and maximum range occurs at α = cos⁻¹((u + √(u² + 8v²))/(4v)). Check: with u = 0 this gives cos α = √8 v/(4v) = 1/√2, α = 45°, the familiar result; a numerical scan with u = 3, v = 10 also gives α ≈ 0.6664 rad, matching the formula.
Examples and data to cite
- For a gun pointing forward instead, the horizontal speed is v cos α + u and the same steps give cos α = (−u + √(u² + 8v²))/(4v).
- The result needs v > u for a positive backward range at small elevations.
Facts to remember
- Velocity of the shot relative to ground = velocity relative to the gun + velocity of the gun.
- Time of flight on level ground: 2V sin α/g, where V sin α is the vertical component.
- Range = horizontal velocity × time of flight.
- At a maximum, dR/dα = 0 and d²R/dα² < 0.