(ii) A uniform chain of length l has one end fixed at a height h above a rough table and rests in a vertical plane so that a portion of it lies in a straight line on the table. Prove that if the chain is on the point of slipping, the length on the table is (l + μh) − √((μ² + 1)h² + 2μlh), where μ is the coefficient of friction.
10 marks · directive: Prove
The core of a good answer
The hanging part is a catenary whose vertex is where the chain meets the table; limiting friction gives c = μx, and y² = s² + c² with y = c + h, s = l − x gives x² − 2(l + μh)x + l² − h² = 0, whose admissible root is x = (l + μh) − √((μ² + 1)h² + 2μlh).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A common catenary problem: the candidate must see that the chain leaves the table tangentially, so the table point is the vertex of the catenary, where the tension is horizontal and equal to wc. Friction on the straight part then fixes c, and the catenary relation y² = s² + c² gives the length.
Answer outline
Introduction
Let w be the weight per unit length and x the length lying on the table. The hanging part has length s = l − x and rises a height h from its lowest point (on the table) to the fixed end.
Step 1: Tension where the chain leaves the table
- The chain on the table is straight and horizontal, so at the point of leaving, the tension is horizontal
- That point is the vertex of the catenary; tension there T₀ = wc
Step 2: Limiting friction on the part on the table
- Normal reaction on the table part = wx; limiting friction = μwx
- On the point of slipping: wc = μwx, so c = μx
Step 3: Catenary relation for the hanging part
- Measured from the directrix, y² = s² + c²
- At the fixed end: y = c + h, s = l − x
- (c + h)² = (l − x)² + c²
- 2ch + h² = (l − x)²
Step 4: Solve for x
- Substitute c = μx: 2μxh + h² = l² − 2lx + x²
- x² − 2(l + μh)x + (l² − h²) = 0
- x = (l + μh) ± √((l + μh)² − l² + h²) = (l + μh) ± √((μ² + 1)h² + 2μlh)
- The plus sign gives x > l, impossible; take the minus sign
Conclusion
Length on the table = (l + μh) − √((μ² + 1)h² + 2μlh). Check: with μ = 0 the formula gives x = l − h, i.e. the hanging part is a vertical straight line of length h, as expected on a smooth table.
Examples and data to cite
- The same method applies to a chain hanging over a rough peg or a chain with both ends on rough horizontal planes; in each case limiting friction fixes the horizontal tension wc.
- The answer was confirmed by solving the quadratic symbolically; the second root exceeds l and is rejected.
Facts to remember
- Common catenary: y = c cosh(x/c), s = c sinh(x/c), y² = c² + s², with y measured from the directrix.
- Horizontal component of tension is constant along a catenary and equals wc; at the vertex the whole tension is wc.
- Limiting friction F = μR.
- Tension at any point: T = wy.