A light elastic string of natural length l has one extremity fixed at a point A and the other attached to a stone (mass m) the weight of which in equilibrium would extend the string to a length b. Show that if the stone be dropped from rest at A, it will come to instantaneous rest at a depth √(b² − l²) below the equilibrium position and this depth is attained in time √(2l/g) + √((b − l)/g) {π − cos⁻¹ √((b − l)/(b + l))}. Prove also that if the greatest depth below A be l cot²(θ/2), then the modulus of elasticity is (1/2) mg tan² θ.
15 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
The stone falls freely through l in time √(2l/g) with speed √(2gl), then moves in simple harmonic motion about the equilibrium point with ω² = g/(b − l) and amplitude √((b − l)² + 2l(b − l)) = √(b² − l²); reaching the lowest point takes (π − cos⁻¹√((b − l)/(b + l)))/ω more. Energy at the greatest depth D = l cot²(θ/2) gives λ = 2lmgD/(D − l)² = (1/2)mg tan²θ.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The motion has two phases: free fall while the string is slack and simple harmonic motion once it is taut. The candidate must find the SHM constants from the equilibrium extension, the amplitude from the speed at the moment the string tightens, and the time from the phase. The last part is a short energy calculation.
Answer outline
Introduction
Natural length l; in equilibrium the extension is b − l, so mg = λ(b − l)/l, i.e. λ = mgl/(b − l). Measure x downward from the equilibrium position (depth b below A).
Step 1: Free fall phase
- The string is slack for the first l of fall
- Time t₁ = √(2l/g); speed at depth l: V² = 2gl
Step 2: Equation of motion when the string is taut
- m d²x/dt² = mg − λ(b − l + x)/l = −(λ/(ml))·m x
- ẍ = −ω²x with ω² = λ/(ml) = g/(b − l)
Step 3: Amplitude
- When the string becomes taut, x = −(b − l) and ẋ² = 2gl
- A² = x² + ẋ²/ω² = (b − l)² + 2gl(b − l)/g = (b − l)(b + l) = b² − l²
- So the stone comes to rest at a depth √(b² − l²) below the equilibrium position
Step 4: Time in the SHM phase
- Write x = −A cos φ, φ = ω(t − t₁) + φ₀; ẋ = Aω sin φ > 0 for 0 < φ < π
- Start: cos φ₀ = (b − l)/A = (b − l)/√((b − l)(b + l)) = √((b − l)/(b + l))
- Lowest point: φ = π
- t₂ = (π − φ₀)/ω = √((b − l)/g){π − cos⁻¹√((b − l)/(b + l))}
- Total time = √(2l/g) + √((b − l)/g){π − cos⁻¹√((b − l)/(b + l))}
Step 5: Modulus from the greatest depth
- Let D be the greatest depth below A; the stone is at rest at A and at D
- Energy: mgD = λ(D − l)²/(2l), so λ = 2lmgD/(D − l)²
- D = l cot²(θ/2) = l cos²(θ/2)/sin²(θ/2)
- D − l = l(cos²(θ/2) − sin²(θ/2))/sin²(θ/2) = l cos θ/sin²(θ/2)
- λ = 2mg·l² cos²(θ/2)/sin²(θ/2) × sin⁴(θ/2)/(l² cos²θ) = 2mg sin²(θ/2)cos²(θ/2)/cos²θ
- = (1/2)mg sin²θ/cos²θ = (1/2)mg tan²θ
Conclusion
The stone comes to instantaneous rest √(b² − l²) below the equilibrium position after time √(2l/g) + √((b − l)/g){π − cos⁻¹√((b − l)/(b + l))}, and a greatest depth l cot²(θ/2) means λ = (1/2)mg tan²θ. Check: a numerical integration with l = 1, b = 1.6, g = 9.8 gave the same time (0.96441 s) and depth (1.2490) as the formulae.
Examples and data to cite
- The greatest depth below A is b + √(b² − l²); consistency with Step 5 follows by substituting λ = mgl/(b − l) into mgD = λ(D − l)²/(2l), which gives (D − b)² = b² − l².
- The same two phase method is used for a bungee jumper: free fall for the slack length, then SHM about the equilibrium stretch.
Facts to remember
- Hooke's law: T = λ × extension/natural length; equilibrium: mg = λ(b − l)/l.
- SHM: ẍ = −ω²x, with v² = ω²(A² − x²) and period 2π/ω.
- Free fall from rest: s = (1/2)gt², v² = 2gs.
- Elastic potential energy of a string: λe²/(2l).