AB is a uniform rod of length l and weight W, which can turn freely about a fixed point in its length distant l/3 from A. AC and BC are light strings each of length (5/6)l, attached to a particle C of weight w. Prove that if W is less than 2w, there will be stable equilibrium with AB inclined to the horizontal at an angle tan⁻¹((W + w)/(4w)).
15 marks · directive: Prove
The core of a good answer
The rod and the taut strings form a rigid isosceles triangle with C at 2l/3 from the midpoint M of AB; potential energy V = (W + w)(l/6) sin θ − (2l/3)w cos θ is stationary at tan θ = −(W + w)/(4w) (end B lower), where V″ > 0, and W < 2w keeps both strings taut.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question is on stability of equilibrium by the energy method. The candidate must fix the geometry of the triangle ACB, write the height of the centres of gravity in terms of the inclination θ, find the stationary point, test the second derivative, and explain the role of the condition W < 2w.
Answer outline
Introduction
Let O be the fixed point, OA = l/3, OB = 2l/3. M, the midpoint of AB and the centre of gravity of the rod, is at OM = l/6 towards B. Triangle ACB has AC = BC = 5l/6, AB = l, so CM ⟂ AB and CM = √((5l/6)² − (l/2)²) = √(16l²/36) = 2l/3. Let AB make angle θ with the horizontal (θ measured so that B is higher when θ > 0), with C on the lower side of AB.
Step 1: Heights above O
- Height of M: (l/6) sin θ
- Height of C: (l/6) sin θ − (2l/3) cos θ
Step 2: Potential energy
- V = W(l/6) sin θ + w[(l/6) sin θ − (2l/3) cos θ]
- V = (W + w)(l/6) sin θ − (2l/3)w cos θ
Step 3: Equilibrium
- dV/dθ = (W + w)(l/6) cos θ + (2l/3)w sin θ = 0
- tan θ = −(W + w)/(4w)
- So AB is inclined at tan⁻¹((W + w)/(4w)) to the horizontal, with B, the end farther from O, the lower
Step 4: Stability
- d²V/dθ² = −(W + w)(l/6) sin θ + (2l/3)w cos θ
- At θ = −α, α = tan⁻¹((W + w)/(4w)), cos θ > 0 and sin θ < 0
- d²V/dθ² = (l/6)√((W + w)² + 16w²) > 0, so V is a minimum and the equilibrium is stable
Step 5: Why W < 2w is needed
- C hangs in equilibrium under w and the two string tensions; both tensions are positive only if the vertical through C meets AB between A and B
- Distance from O, along the rod, of the point vertically above C: l/6 + (2l/3) tan θ = l/6 − l(W + w)/(6w) = −lW/(6w)
- This lies between A (−l/3) and B (2l/3) iff lW/(6w) < l/3, i.e. W < 2w
- If W ≥ 2w, string BC would be slack and the rigid triangle analysis fails
Conclusion
When W < 2w the system rests in stable equilibrium with AB inclined at tan⁻¹((W + w)/(4w)) to the horizontal. Check: at W = 2w the point above C coincides with A, so the tension in BC is exactly zero, confirming the boundary of the condition.
Examples and data to cite
- The other stationary value of θ (C above AB) gives a maximum of V and an unstable position, and is not physically possible with strings.
- Energy methods for stability (minimum potential energy) apply equally to other statics problems involving rods and strings.
Facts to remember
- Equilibrium of a conservative system: dV/dθ = 0; stable if d²V/dθ² > 0 (potential energy minimum).
- The centre of gravity of a uniform rod is its midpoint.
- Altitude of an isosceles triangle with equal sides p and base q: √(p² − q²/4).
- A light string can only pull, so its tension must be non-negative.