(i) For a scalar point function φ and a vector point function F⃗, prove that
∇ × (φF⃗) = (∇φ) × F⃗ + φ(∇ × F⃗)
If r⃗ = xî + yĵ + zk̂ and r = |r⃗|, then verify the above identity for φ = 1/r and F⃗ = r⃗.
10 marks · directive: Prove
The core of a good answer
Writing ∇ × (φF⃗) = Σ î × ∂(φF⃗)/∂x and using the product rule gives (∇φ) × F⃗ + φ(∇ × F⃗); for φ = 1/r, F⃗ = r⃗ both sides are 0⃗, since ∇(1/r) = −r⃗/r³ is parallel to r⃗ and ∇ × r⃗ = 0⃗.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The proof uses the operator form of curl and the product rule for differentiation. The verification asks the candidate to compute both sides independently for a specific φ and F⃗ and show they agree.
Answer outline
Introduction
Use ∇ × G⃗ = î × ∂G⃗/∂x + ĵ × ∂G⃗/∂y + k̂ × ∂G⃗/∂z.
Step 1: Proof
- ∇ × (φF⃗) = Σ î × ∂(φF⃗)/∂x = Σ î × [(∂φ/∂x)F⃗ + φ ∂F⃗/∂x]
- = Σ (∂φ/∂x)î × F⃗ + φ Σ î × ∂F⃗/∂x
- = [(∂φ/∂x)î + (∂φ/∂y)ĵ + (∂φ/∂z)k̂] × F⃗ + φ(∇ × F⃗)
- = (∇φ) × F⃗ + φ(∇ × F⃗)
Step 2: Left side for φ = 1/r, F⃗ = r⃗
- φF⃗ = (x/r)î + (y/r)ĵ + (z/r)k̂
- î component of curl: ∂(z/r)/∂y − ∂(y/r)/∂z = −zy/r³ + yz/r³ = 0
- Similarly the ĵ and k̂ components are 0, so LHS = 0⃗
Step 3: Right side
- ∂r/∂x = x/r, so ∇(1/r) = −(1/r²)(x/r, y/r, z/r) = −r⃗/r³
- (∇φ) × F⃗ = −(r⃗ × r⃗)/r³ = 0⃗
- ∇ × r⃗ = (∂z/∂y − ∂y/∂z)î + ... = 0⃗, so φ(∇ × F⃗) = 0⃗
- RHS = 0⃗
Conclusion
The identity ∇ × (φF⃗) = (∇φ) × F⃗ + φ(∇ × F⃗) holds in general, and for φ = 1/r, F⃗ = r⃗ both sides are the zero vector. A symbolic computation of each side confirmed this.
Examples and data to cite
- More generally ∇ × (f(r) r⃗) = 0⃗ for any differentiable f, because ∇f(r) = f′(r) r⃗/r is parallel to r⃗; so every central field is irrotational.
- The companion identity for divergence is ∇·(φF⃗) = (∇φ)·F⃗ + φ(∇·F⃗); with φ = 1/r³ and F⃗ = r⃗ it gives ∇·(r⃗/r³) = 0 for r ≠ 0.
Facts to remember
- ∇ × G⃗ = Σ î × ∂G⃗/∂x.
- ∇r = r⃗/r and ∇(1/r) = −r⃗/r³.
- ∇ × r⃗ = 0⃗ and ∇·r⃗ = 3.
- a⃗ × a⃗ = 0⃗ for any vector a⃗.