(ii) If r⃗ = a cos t î + a sin t ĵ + bt k̂, then show that
|r⃗′ × r⃗″|² = a²(a² + b²) and [r⃗′ r⃗″ r⃗‴] = a²b
10 marks · directive: Show
Answer
The core of a good answer
For the circular helix, r⃗′ × r⃗″ = ab sin t î − ab cos t ĵ + a² k̂, so |r⃗′ × r⃗″|² = a²b² + a⁴ = a²(a² + b²), and (r⃗′ × r⃗″)·r⃗‴ = a²b sin²t + a²b cos²t = a²b.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A direct computation with the derivatives of the circular helix; these two quantities are exactly what is needed for its curvature and torsion, so the part also tests knowledge of the Frenet Serret formulae.
Answer outline
Introduction
r⃗ = (a cos t, a sin t, bt). Differentiate three times.
Step 1: Derivatives
- r⃗′ = −a sin t î + a cos t ĵ + b k̂
- r⃗″ = −a cos t î − a sin t ĵ
- r⃗‴ = a sin t î − a cos t ĵ
Step 2: Cross product
- î: (a cos t)(0) − b(−a sin t) = ab sin t
- ĵ: b(−a cos t) − (−a sin t)(0) = −ab cos t
- k̂: (−a sin t)(−a sin t) − (a cos t)(−a cos t) = a² sin²t + a² cos²t = a²
- r⃗′ × r⃗″ = ab sin t î − ab cos t ĵ + a² k̂
Step 3: Magnitude squared
- |r⃗′ × r⃗″|² = a²b² sin²t + a²b² cos²t + a⁴ = a²b² + a⁴ = a²(a² + b²)
Step 4: Scalar triple product
- [r⃗′ r⃗″ r⃗‴] = (r⃗′ × r⃗″)·r⃗‴
- = (ab sin t)(a sin t) + (−ab cos t)(−a cos t) + a²·0
- = a²b(sin²t + cos²t) = a²b
Conclusion
|r⃗′ × r⃗″|² = a²(a² + b²) and [r⃗′ r⃗″ r⃗‴] = a²b, both independent of t. Hence the helix has constant curvature κ = |a|/(a² + b²) and constant torsion τ = b/(a² + b²).
Examples and data to cite
- Using |r⃗′|² = a² + b²: κ = |r⃗′ × r⃗″|/|r⃗′|³ = |a|√(a² + b²)/(a² + b²)^(3/2) = |a|/(a² + b²).
- τ = [r⃗′ r⃗″ r⃗‴]/|r⃗′ × r⃗″|² = a²b/(a²(a² + b²)) = b/(a² + b²).
Facts
Facts to remember
- Scalar triple product [a⃗ b⃗ c⃗] = (a⃗ × b⃗)·c⃗, the determinant of the components.
- Curvature κ = |r⃗′ × r⃗″|/|r⃗′|³; torsion τ = [r⃗′ r⃗″ r⃗‴]/|r⃗′ × r⃗″|².
- sin²t + cos²t = 1.
- The circular helix has constant curvature and torsion.