Let G be a group of order pq, where p and q are primes. Show that either G is an abelian group or no non-identity element commutes with every element of G.
10 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
The centre Z(G) is a subgroup whose order divides pq; if it had order p or q, G/Z(G) would have prime order and so be cyclic, forcing G to be abelian and Z(G) = G, a contradiction. Hence Z(G) = G (G abelian) or Z(G) = {e} (no non-identity element commutes with everything).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The statement 'no non-identity element commutes with every element' is exactly the statement Z(G) = {e}. So the task is to show that the centre of a group of order pq is either the whole group or trivial. The key tool is the standard lemma that if G/Z(G) is cyclic then G is abelian, combined with Lagrange's theorem.
Answer outline
Introduction
Let Z(G) = {z ∈ G : zg = gz for all g ∈ G}. It is a normal subgroup of G. We use Lagrange's theorem on |Z(G)| and the G/Z(G) lemma.
Step 1: Possible orders of Z(G)
- Z(G) is a subgroup, so by Lagrange |Z(G)| divides |G| = pq.
- Hence |Z(G)| ∈ {1, p, q, pq} (when p = q the list is {1, p, p²}).
- If |Z(G)| = pq then Z(G) = G, i.e. G is abelian. If |Z(G)| = 1 then Z(G) = {e}, i.e. no non-identity element commutes with every element. It remains to rule out the middle cases.
Step 2: Lemma: G/Z(G) cyclic implies G abelian
- Suppose G/Z(G) = ⟨gZ(G)⟩. Then every x ∈ G can be written x = gⁱz₁ with z₁ ∈ Z(G), and every y = gʲz₂ with z₂ ∈ Z(G).
- xy = gⁱz₁gʲz₂ = g^(i+j) z₁z₂ = gʲz₂gⁱz₁ = yx, since z₁, z₂ commute with everything and powers of g commute with each other.
- So G is abelian.
Step 3: Ruling out |Z(G)| = p or q
- If |Z(G)| = p, then |G/Z(G)| = pq/p = q, a prime.
- A group of prime order is cyclic, so G/Z(G) is cyclic, and by Step 2 G is abelian.
- But then Z(G) = G has order pq ≠ p, a contradiction. The same argument works for |Z(G)| = q (and for |Z(G)| = p when p = q, giving quotient of order p).
Step 4: Conclusion of the dichotomy
- Therefore |Z(G)| = pq or |Z(G)| = 1.
- Case |Z(G)| = pq: G is abelian.
- Case |Z(G)| = 1: the only element commuting with every element of G is e.
Conclusion
Either Z(G) = G and G is abelian, or Z(G) = {e}. Check: S₃ has order 6 = 2·3 and trivial centre, while ℤ₆ has order 6 and is abelian, so both alternatives occur.
Examples and data to cite
- S₃ (order 6): Z(S₃) = {e}, illustrating the second alternative.
- ℤ₁₅ (order 15 = 3·5): abelian, illustrating the first alternative; in fact every group of order 15 is cyclic.
Facts to remember
- Lagrange's theorem: the order of a subgroup of a finite group divides the order of the group.
- The centre Z(G) of any group is a normal subgroup.
- If G/Z(G) is cyclic then G is abelian; equivalently G/Z(G) is never a non-trivial cyclic group.
- Every group of prime order is cyclic.
- When p = q, |G| = p²: the centre of a non-trivial finite p-group is non-trivial, so |Z(G)| = 1 is impossible, and the argument above then shows every group of order p² is abelian.