Show that every non-zero prime ideal in a Euclidean Domain is maximal.
10 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
A Euclidean domain is a principal ideal domain, so a non-zero prime ideal is P = (p) with p a prime element; if (p) ⊆ (m) ⊆ R then p = mr, primality gives m ∈ P (so (m) = P) or r ∈ P (so m is a unit and (m) = R). Hence P is maximal.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for a proof that in a Euclidean domain R the non-zero prime ideals coincide with the maximal ideals (the zero ideal is prime but not maximal unless R is a field, which is why 'non-zero' is in the hypothesis). The natural route is to first prove that every ideal of a Euclidean domain is principal, then use the defining property of a prime ideal and cancellation in an integral domain.
Answer outline
Introduction
Let R be a Euclidean domain with Euclidean function d : R \ {0} → ℕ ∪ {0}, so for a, b ∈ R with b ≠ 0 there exist q, r with a = bq + r and r = 0 or d(r) < d(b). Let P be a non-zero prime ideal.
Step 1: Every ideal of R is principal
- Let I be a non-zero ideal and choose b ∈ I, b ≠ 0, with d(b) minimal among non-zero elements of I.
- For a ∈ I write a = bq + r. Then r = a - bq ∈ I.
- If r ≠ 0 then d(r) < d(b), contradicting minimality; so r = 0 and a = bq.
- Hence I = (b), and R is a principal ideal domain.
Step 2: Write P = (p)
- By Step 1, P = (p) for some p ≠ 0, and p is not a unit since P ≠ R (a prime ideal is proper).
Step 3: P is maximal
- Let M be an ideal with P ⊆ M ⊆ R. By Step 1, M = (m).
- p ∈ M, so p = mr for some r ∈ R. Thus mr ∈ P.
- Since P is prime, m ∈ P or r ∈ P.
- If m ∈ P then M = (m) ⊆ P, so M = P.
- If r ∈ P then r = ps for some s, so p = mps, i.e. p(1 - ms) = 0.
- R is an integral domain and p ≠ 0, so 1 - ms = 0, ms = 1, m is a unit and M = R.
Step 4: Alternative view
- Equivalently R/P is an integral domain (P prime); one can show every non-zero element of R/P is invertible using the argument above, so R/P is a field and P is maximal.
Conclusion
Every ideal between P and R equals P or R, so P is maximal. Check with R = ℤ: the non-zero prime ideals are pℤ, and ℤ/pℤ is a field, so they are maximal; the zero ideal (0) is prime but not maximal, which is why it is excluded.
Examples and data to cite
- ℤ with d(n) = |n|: (5) is prime and maximal, ℤ/5ℤ is a field.
- F[x] for a field F with d = degree: (x² + 1) in ℝ[x] is prime and maximal, ℝ[x]/(x² + 1) ≅ ℂ.
Facts to remember
- A Euclidean domain is a principal ideal domain (proof by choosing an element of least Euclidean value).
- An ideal P is prime if P ≠ R and ab ∈ P implies a ∈ P or b ∈ P.
- An ideal M is maximal if M ≠ R and there is no ideal strictly between M and R; equivalently R/M is a field.
- Cancellation holds in an integral domain: if p ≠ 0 and px = 0 then x = 0.
- In a PID, non-zero prime ideals are exactly the ideals generated by irreducible (prime) elements.