Show that the function f(z) = √|xy| is not analytic at the origin, although Cauchy-Riemann equations are satisfied at that point.
10 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
With u = √|xy| and v = 0, all four partial derivatives at (0, 0) are 0, so the Cauchy-Riemann equations hold there; but [f(z) - f(0)]/z along y = mx tends to √|m|/(1 + im), which depends on m, so f'(0) does not exist and f is not analytic at the origin.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
This is the classic counterexample showing that the Cauchy-Riemann equations are necessary but not sufficient for differentiability: the partial derivatives exist at the origin but are not continuous there (u is not differentiable as a real function). The answer must compute the partials from the definition and then show that the complex derivative fails to exist by approaching along different paths.
Answer outline
Introduction
Write f(z) = u(x, y) + i v(x, y) with u(x, y) = √|xy| and v(x, y) = 0, and f(0) = 0.
Step 1: Partial derivatives at the origin
- u_x(0, 0) = lim_{h→0} [u(h, 0) - u(0, 0)]/h = lim (0 - 0)/h = 0.
- u_y(0, 0) = lim_{k→0} [u(0, k) - u(0, 0)]/k = 0.
- v_x(0, 0) = v_y(0, 0) = 0 since v ≡ 0.
Step 2: Cauchy-Riemann equations hold
- u_x = 0 = v_y and u_y = 0 = -v_x at (0, 0).
Step 3: f'(0) does not exist
- f'(0) would be lim_{z→0} [f(z) - f(0)]/z = lim √|xy|/(x + iy).
- Along y = mx with x → 0⁺: √|m|·|x| / (x(1 + im)) = √|m|/(1 + im).
- For m = 0 (real axis) the limit is 0; for m = 1 it is 1/(1 + i) = (1 - i)/2.
- Different paths give different limits, so the limit does not exist.
Step 4: Not analytic
- Analyticity at 0 requires differentiability in a neighbourhood of 0, in particular at 0 itself; f is not differentiable at 0, so it is not analytic there.
- Reason the CR test fails: u is not (real) differentiable at the origin, since u(h, h) = |h| is not o(|h|); the sufficient condition (continuous partials satisfying CR) is not met.
Conclusion
The Cauchy-Riemann equations are satisfied at 0 but f is not differentiable, hence not analytic, at the origin. Numerical check: at x = 10⁻⁶ the quotient along m = 0.5, 1, 2 equals 0.566 - 0.283i, 0.5 - 0.5i and 0.283 - 0.566i, matching √m/(1 + im).
Facts to remember
- Cauchy-Riemann equations: u_x = v_y, u_y = -v_x.
- CR equations are necessary for complex differentiability at a point; they become sufficient when u and v are (real) differentiable there, for example when the partials are continuous.
- f is analytic at z₀ if it is differentiable at every point of some neighbourhood of z₀.
- The complex derivative limit must be the same along every path z → z₀.