A function f is defined on [0, 1] by
f(x) = x², when x is rational
f(x) = x³, when x is irrational
Evaluate lower integral ∫̲₀¹ f and upper integral ∫̅₀¹ f. Does the integral ∫₀¹ f exist ?
20 marks · directive: Evaluate
The core of a good answer
On [0, 1], x³ ≤ x², and by density of rationals and irrationals the supremum of f on [x_{i-1}, x_i] is x_i² and the infimum is x_{i-1}³; hence the upper integral is ∫₀¹ x² dx = 1/3 and the lower integral is ∫₀¹ x³ dx = 1/4. Since 1/4 ≠ 1/3, f is not Riemann integrable on [0, 1].
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question requires the Darboux (upper and lower) integrals from the definition: compute Mᵢ and mᵢ on a general subinterval using density arguments, form U(P, f) and L(P, f), and take the infimum and supremum over partitions. Then apply the criterion that f is Riemann integrable iff the two are equal.
Answer outline
Introduction
Let P = {0 = x₀ < x₁ < ... < xₙ = 1} be any partition, Δxᵢ = xᵢ - x_{i-1}, Mᵢ = sup f and mᵢ = inf f on [x_{i-1}, xᵢ].
Step 1: Supremum on a subinterval
- For any x ∈ [0, 1], f(x) ≤ x² because x³ ≤ x² there.
- So f ≤ x² ≤ xᵢ² on [x_{i-1}, xᵢ].
- Rationals rₖ → xᵢ from inside the interval give f(rₖ) = rₖ² → xᵢ². Hence Mᵢ = xᵢ².
Step 2: Infimum on a subinterval
- f(x) ≥ x³ ≥ x_{i-1}³ on the subinterval.
- Irrationals sₖ → x_{i-1} give f(sₖ) = sₖ³ → x_{i-1}³. Hence mᵢ = x_{i-1}³.
Step 3: Upper integral
- U(P, f) = Σ xᵢ² Δxᵢ, the right-endpoint upper sum of the continuous increasing function x² on [0, 1].
- U(P, f) ≥ ∫₀¹ x² dx, and U(P, f) → ∫₀¹ x² dx as the mesh → 0.
- So upper integral = inf_P U(P, f) = ∫₀¹ x² dx = 1/3.
Step 4: Lower integral
- L(P, f) = Σ x_{i-1}³ Δxᵢ, the left-endpoint lower sum of the increasing function x³.
- L(P, f) ≤ ∫₀¹ x³ dx and L(P, f) → ∫₀¹ x³ dx as mesh → 0.
- So lower integral = sup_P L(P, f) = 1/4.
Step 5: Existence
- Lower integral 1/4 ≠ upper integral 1/3, so f is not Riemann integrable on [0, 1].
- Equivalently, f is discontinuous at every x ∈ (0, 1) (where x² ≠ x³), a set of positive measure, so Lebesgue's criterion also fails.
Conclusion
Lower integral = 1/4, upper integral = 1/3, and ∫₀¹ f does not exist in the Riemann sense. Numerical check with 100000 equal subintervals: U ≈ 0.333338, L ≈ 0.249995.
Facts to remember
- Darboux sums: U(P, f) = Σ Mᵢ Δxᵢ, L(P, f) = Σ mᵢ Δxᵢ; upper integral = inf U, lower integral = sup L.
- f is Riemann integrable iff the upper and lower integrals are equal.
- Rationals and irrationals are both dense in ℝ.
- For 0 ≤ x ≤ 1, x³ ≤ x², with equality only at 0 and 1.
- ∫₀¹ x² dx = 1/3, ∫₀¹ x³ dx = 1/4.