Find the integral surface of the equations dx/(xz − y) = dy/(yz − x) = dz/(1 − z²).
10 marks · directive: Find
The core of a good answer
The two independent integrals are (x + y)(1 + z) = c₁ and (x − y)(1 − z) = c₂, so the integral surfaces are F((x + y)(1 + z), (x − y)(1 − z)) = 0 for an arbitrary function F; these are the integral surfaces of (xz − y)p + (yz − x)q = 1 − z².
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
These are Lagrange's auxiliary (characteristic) equations. The method is to find two independent first integrals u = c₁ and v = c₂ by forming suitable combinations of the ratios (here, adding and subtracting the first two), and then to write the general integral surface as an arbitrary relation F(u, v) = 0. A full answer shows both integrals, checks them, and states the surface.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given P = xz − y, Q = yz − x, R = 1 − z². The trick is that P + Q and P − Q both factor neatly, each with x + y or x − y as a factor, so each combination separates into one variable against z.
Step 1: First integral from adding the first two ratios
- P + Q = xz − y + yz − x = (x + y)z − (x + y) = (x + y)(z − 1)
- So d(x + y)/[(x + y)(z − 1)] = dz/[(1 − z)(1 + z)]
- Multiply both sides by (z − 1): d(x + y)/(x + y) = −dz/(1 + z)
- Integrate: ln(x + y) = −ln(1 + z) + constant
- Hence (x + y)(1 + z) = c₁
Step 2: Second integral from subtracting
- P − Q = xz − y − yz + x = (x − y)z + (x − y) = (x − y)(z + 1)
- So d(x − y)/[(x − y)(z + 1)] = dz/[(1 − z)(1 + z)]
- Multiply by (z + 1): d(x − y)/(x − y) = dz/(1 − z)
- Integrate: ln(x − y) = −ln(1 − z) + constant
- Hence (x − y)(1 − z) = c₂
Step 3: Check the integrals
- For u = (x + y)(1 + z): P u_x + Q u_y + R u_z = (1 + z)(P + Q) + (x + y)(1 − z²) = (1 + z)(x + y)(z − 1) + (x + y)(1 − z²) = 0
- For v = (x − y)(1 − z): (1 − z)(P − Q) − (x − y)(1 − z²) = (1 − z)(x − y)(1 + z) − (x − y)(1 − z²) = 0
- Both are constant along every integral curve, and they are independent (one involves x + y, the other x − y).
Step 4: Integral surface
- The integral curves are the intersections of the two families u = c₁, v = c₂.
- Any surface generated by these curves is F((x + y)(1 + z), (x − y)(1 − z)) = 0, F arbitrary.
- Equivalently (x − y)(1 − z) = φ((x + y)(1 + z)) for an arbitrary φ.
- A particular surface follows once a curve through which it must pass is given; for instance their product gives (x² − y²)(1 − z²) = constant as one member of the family.
Conclusion
The integral surface is F((x + y)(1 + z), (x − y)(1 − z)) = 0. Both integrals were checked by direct substitution (Python, sympy) and satisfy P u_x + Q u_y + R u_z = 0 identically.
Examples and data to cite
- A similar device (multipliers 1, 1, 0 and 1, −1, 0) is used for systems where P and Q are symmetric in x and y.
- The associated linear PDE is (xz − y)p + (yz − x)q = 1 − z², whose general solution is the same F(u, v) = 0.
Facts to remember
- Lagrange's method: for Pp + Qq = R, the auxiliary equations dx/P = dy/Q = dz/R give two independent integrals u = c₁, v = c₂; the general solution is F(u, v) = 0.
- Method of multipliers: if l, m, n are chosen so that lP + mQ + nR is simple, then (l dx + m dy + n dz)/(lP + mQ + nR) equals each ratio.
- A first integral u satisfies P ∂u/∂x + Q ∂u/∂y + R ∂u/∂z = 0.
- ∫ dz/(1 + z) = ln(1 + z) and ∫ dz/(1 − z) = −ln(1 − z).