Suppose that there is an infinitely long cylinder of radius 'a' placed in a uniform stream having velocity −Vî. Then using Milne-Thomson's circle theorem, what will be its complex velocity potential ? If in addition, a circulation round the cylinder of k is produced, find out the stagnation points. Do they produce a lifting tendency in the vertical direction ? Explain how.
15 marks · directive: Find and explain
The core of a good answer
With f(z) = Vz the circle theorem gives w = V(z + a²/z); adding circulation k, w = V(z + a²/z) + (ik/2π) log z, with stagnation points where sin θ = −k/(4πaV) on the cylinder (if k < 4πaV); the circulation makes the flow asymmetric and gives a lift ρVk per unit length perpendicular to the stream (zero drag).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Three linked tasks: apply the circle theorem to the uniform stream, add a line vortex and locate stagnation points from dw/dz = 0 (with the three cases of k against 4πaV), and use Blasius' theorem (or the Kutta-Joukowski result) to show that circulation, not the stagnation points themselves, produces a net vertical force.
Answer outline
Introduction
Use w = φ + iψ with dw/dz = −u + iv (velocity = −∇φ, as in Milne-Thomson). A uniform stream with velocity −Vî (that is, flowing in the negative x direction) has f(z) = Vz, since −dw/dz = −V = u − iv gives u = −V, v = 0. The cylinder is |z| = a, and f has no singularities inside it.
Step 1: Circle theorem
- Milne-Thomson: if f(z) is the complex potential with no singularities in |z| ≤ a, then w = f(z) + f̄(a²/z) has |z| = a as a stream line.
- f(z) = Vz, f̄(z) = Vz (V real), so w = V(z + a²/z)
- On z = ae^(iθ): w = 2Va cos θ, real, so ψ = 0 on the cylinder.
Step 2: Add circulation k
- A line vortex of circulation k (anticlockwise) at the origin has w = (ik/2π) log z in this convention.
- Since log z has constant real part on |z| = a, ψ stays constant on the circle.
- w = V(z + a²/z) + (ik/2π) log z
Step 3: Stagnation points
- dw/dz = V(1 − a²/z²) + ik/(2πz) = 0
- V z² + (ik/2π) z − V a² = 0
- z = −ik/(4πV) ± √(16π²a²V² − k²)/(4πV)
- If k < 4πaV: two points on the cylinder, |z| = a, at sin θ = −k/(4πaV) (both in the lower half, symmetric about the y axis)
- If k = 4πaV: they merge at z = −ia
- If k > 4πaV: z = −i[k ± √(k² − 16π²a²V²)]/(4πV); one lies in the fluid on the negative y axis, the other inside the cylinder
Step 4: Lifting tendency (Blasius)
- X − iY = (iρ/2) ∮ (dw/dz)² dz around the cylinder
- (dw/dz)² has residue at z = 0 equal to 2V(ik/2π) = iVk/π
- ∮ (dw/dz)² dz = 2πi(iVk/π) = −2Vk
- X − iY = (iρ/2)(−2Vk) = −iρVk, so X = 0 and Y = ρVk
- Physically: at the top the vortex velocity adds to the stream (which flows in the −x direction), at the bottom it opposes it; by Bernoulli pressure is lower on top, so there is an upward force ρVk per unit length.
Conclusion
w = V(z + a²/z) without circulation (stagnation points z = ±a, no force: d'Alembert's paradox) and w = V(z + a²/z) + (ik/2π) log z with circulation. The stagnation points move down to sin θ = −k/(4πaV), and the cylinder feels a lift ρVk per unit length at right angles to the stream and no drag. The residue and roots were checked with sympy.
Examples and data to cite
- The Magnus effect on spinning balls and rotor ships (Flettner rotor, 1920s) is the physical counterpart of lift from circulation.
- The Kutta-Joukowski theorem (developed in the early 20th century) generalises the result L = ρVΓ to any two dimensional body in steady potential flow.
Facts to remember
- Milne-Thomson circle theorem: w = f(z) + f̄(a²/z).
- Complex potential of a line vortex of circulation k at the origin: (ik/2π) log z when dw/dz = −u + iv.
- Blasius theorem: X − iY = (iρ/2) ∮ (dw/dz)² dz.
- Kutta-Joukowski: lift per unit length = ρVk, perpendicular to the stream; drag is zero in steady inviscid flow.
- Without circulation the pressure is symmetric and the resultant force is zero (d'Alembert's paradox).