The fixed-ended bar ABCD consists of three prismatic segments, as shown in the figure. The end segments have a cross-sectional area A₁ = 840 mm² and length L₁ = 200 mm. The middle segment has a cross-sectional area A₂ = 1260 mm² and length L₂ = 250 mm. Loads P_B and P_C are equal to 25·5 kN and 17·0 kN, respectively.
(i) Determine the reactions R_A and R_D at the fixed supports.
(ii) Determine the compressive axial force F_BC in the middle segment of the bar.
[Figure, described: the bar is horizontal between fixed walls at A (left) and D (right): AB (area A₁, length L₁), BC (area A₂, length L₂), CD (area A₁, length L₁). P_B acts at B along the axis towards the right; P_C acts at C along the axis towards the left.]
10 marks · directive: Determine
The core of a good answer
R_A = 10·5 kN acting to the left and R_D = 2·0 kN acting to the right; AB carries 10·5 kN tension, CD 2·0 kN tension and the middle segment a compressive force F_BC = 15·0 kN.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A statically indeterminate axial bar: one equilibrium equation and two unknown reactions. The method is to add a compatibility condition: since both ends are fixed, the total change in length of A to D is zero. The axial forces in the three segments are written in terms of one unknown, and the elongations δ = NL/EA are summed (E cancels).
Answer outline
Introduction
Let N₁, N₂, N₃ be the tensile forces in AB, BC and CD. Equilibrium of joints B and C gives N₂ = N₁ − P_B and N₃ = N₂ + P_C. Same material throughout, so E cancels.
Step 1: Compatibility
- δ_AB + δ_BC + δ_CD = 0
- N₁L₁/A₁ + N₂L₂/A₂ + N₃L₁/A₁ = 0
- N₁(200/840) + (N₁ − 25·5)(250/1260) + (N₁ − 25·5 + 17·0)(200/840) = 0
Step 2: Solve
- 0·2381N₁ + 0·1984(N₁ − 25·5) + 0·2381(N₁ − 8·5) = 0
- 0·6746N₁ = 5·0595 + 2·0238 = 7·0833
- N₁ = 10·5 kN (tension)
- N₂ = 10·5 − 25·5 = −15·0 kN (compression)
- N₃ = −15·0 + 17·0 = 2·0 kN (tension)
Step 3: Reactions
- Wall at A pulls the bar to the left: R_A = 10·5 kN (←)
- Wall at D pulls the bar to the right: R_D = 2·0 kN (→)
- Check ΣF_x: −10·5 + 25·5 − 17·0 + 2·0 = 0
Step 4: Middle segment
- F_BC = 15·0 kN compression
Conclusion
R_A = 10·5 kN (to the left), R_D = 2·0 kN (to the right) and F_BC = 15·0 kN (compressive). The elongations add to zero: 10·5(0·2381) − 15(0·1984) + 2(0·2381) = 0. (Recomputed in Python.)
Facts to remember
- Axial deformation of a prismatic segment: δ = NL/(AE), since a uniform rod acts as a spring of stiffness proportional to EA/L.
- Statically indeterminate structures need compatibility of deformations in addition to equilibrium.
- For a bar fixed at both ends, the sum of segment elongations is zero.
- Stress = E × strain within the elastic range.