A turbine shaft of diameter d is under a thrust load P and torque T (as shown in the figure). Calculate the largest permissible value of the load P if the allowable normal stress is not to exceed σ_all.
Given : d = 60 mm, T = 2 kN.m, σ_all = 220 MPa
[Figure, described: a solid circular shaft of diameter d with an axial force P at each end directed into the shaft (compressive thrust) and equal and opposite torques T at the two ends.]
10 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
With τ = 16T/πd³ = 47·16 MPa and σ = −P/A, setting the larger principal stress magnitude σ/2 + √((σ/2)² + τ²) equal to 220 MPa gives σ = 209·9 MPa compressive and P_max ≈ 593 kN.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A combined loading problem: axial compression and torsion produce a plane stress state on the shaft surface. The method is to write the principal stresses with Mohr's circle formula and limit the numerically largest normal (principal) stress to σ_all, then solve for P.
Answer outline
Introduction
A = πd²/4 = 2827·4 mm². Surface stresses: σ_x = −P/A (compression), τ = 16T/(πd³). The compressive principal stress has the larger magnitude.
Step 1: Torsional shear
- τ = 16 × 2 × 10⁶ / (π × 60³) = 47·16 MPa
Step 2: Principal stress
- σ₂ = −s/2 − √((s/2)² + τ²), with s = P/A
- Condition: s/2 + √((s/2)² + τ²) = 220
Step 3: Solve for s
- √((s/2)² + τ²) = 220 − s/2
- s²/4 + τ² = 220² − 220s + s²/4
- s = (220² − τ²)/220 = (48400 − 2223·8)/220 = 209·89 MPa
Step 4: Load
- P = sA = 209·89 × 2827·4 = 593·4 × 10³ N
- P_max ≈ 593 kN
Conclusion
P_max ≈ 593 kN. Check: σ₁ = +10·1 MPa and σ₂ = −220·0 MPa; maximum in-plane shear 115·1 MPa (which would govern only if a shear limit were also given). (Recomputed in Python.)
Examples and data to cite
- Without torque the limit would be P = 220 × 2827·4 N = 622 kN; the torque reduces the permissible thrust by about 5%.
Facts to remember
- Maximum torsional shear stress in a solid circular shaft (at the outer surface): τ = 2T/(πR³) = 16T/(πd³).
- Principal stresses: σ₁,₂ = σ_x/2 ± √((σ_x/2)² + τ²) for σ_y = 0 (centre and radius of Mohr's circle).
- Maximum in-plane shear equals the radius of Mohr's circle: τ_max = √((σ_x/2)² + τ²).
- Axial stress: σ = P/A.