A steel tube has a mean diameter of 100 mm and a thickness of 3 mm. Calculate the torque which can be transmitted by the tube with a factor of safety of 2·25, if the criterion of failure is :
(i) Maximum shear stress
(ii) Maximum strain energy
(iii) Maximum shear strain energy
The elastic limit of the steel in tension is 225 MN/m² and Poisson's ratio v is 0·3.
20 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
In pure shear σ₁ = τ, σ₂ = −τ; with a design stress 225/2·25 = 100 MPa the allowable shear is 50 MPa (maximum shear stress), 62·02 MPa (maximum strain energy) and 57·74 MPa (shear strain energy), so T = τ × 2πr²t = 2·36, 2·92 and 2·72 kN·m.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Apply three theories of failure to the pure shear state of a thin tube in torsion. For each theory, write the equivalent stress in terms of τ, equate it to σ_e/FS, find τ, then convert to torque with the thin-tube relation T = 2πr_m²tτ (or with the exact polar moment as a check).
Answer outline
Introduction
Thin tube: r_m = 50 mm, t = 3 mm, so T = 2πr_m²tτ = 2π(0·05)²(0·003)τ = 4·712 × 10⁻⁵ τ (N·m with τ in Pa). Permissible tensile stress σ = 225/2·25 = 100 MPa. Principal stresses in torsion: σ₁ = τ, σ₂ = −τ, σ₃ = 0.
Step 1: Maximum shear stress (Tresca)
- (σ₁ − σ₂)/2 = σ/2
- τ = 100/2 = 50 MPa
- T = 4·712 × 10⁻⁵ × 50 × 10⁶ = 2356 N·m = 2·36 kN·m
Step 2: Maximum strain energy (Haigh)
- σ₁² + σ₂² − 2νσ₁σ₂ = σ²
- τ²(2 + 2ν) = 100², so τ = 100/√2·6 = 62·02 MPa
- T = 4·712 × 10⁻⁵ × 62·02 × 10⁶ = 2922 N·m = 2·92 kN·m
Step 3: Maximum shear strain energy (von Mises)
- σ₁² + σ₂² − σ₁σ₂ = σ²
- 3τ² = 100², so τ = 57·74 MPa
- T = 4·712 × 10⁻⁵ × 57·74 × 10⁶ = 2721 N·m = 2·72 kN·m
Step 4: Check with exact polar moment
- J = π(103⁴ − 97⁴)/32 = 2·358 × 10⁶ mm⁴; T = τJ/51·5 mm
- Gives 2·29, 2·84 and 2·64 kN·m, about 3% lower, because the outer fibre stress exceeds the mean-radius value
Conclusion
Allowable torques: 2·36 kN·m (maximum shear stress), 2·92 kN·m (maximum strain energy), 2·72 kN·m (distortion energy). The maximum shear stress theory gives the lowest, most conservative torque here. (Recomputed in Python.)
Examples and data to cite
- The exact annulus result (Step 4) is about 3% below the thin-tube estimate, so the thin-tube formula is slightly unconservative for this tube.
Facts to remember
- Thin closed tube in torsion (Bredt): τ = T/(2A_m t), with A_m = πr_m² for a circular tube.
- Tresca (maximum shear stress): yield when the maximum shear stress reaches the shear yield strength, σ_y/2 in a tensile test.
- Total strain energy theory: yield when strain energy per unit volume reaches its value at the elastic limit; with Hooke's law this gives σ₁² + σ₂² − 2νσ₁σ₂ = σ_y².
- von Mises (distortion energy): σ₁² + σ₂² − σ₁σ₂ = σ_y², so in pure shear τ_y = σ_y/√3 = 0·577σ_y.
- Pure shear: σ₁ = τ, σ₂ = −τ.