A shaft carries three eccentric masses of 1 kg each at radial distances of 20, 30 and 20 mm with the central plane 50 mm apart. Their angular positions are 120° apart. If the shaft is balanced by adding two masses at a radius of 700 mm and at distances of 100 mm each from the central plane of the middle eccentric,
(i) Determine the magnitudes and angular positions of the masses.
(ii) If one of the masses is shifted to a radius of 50 mm due to space constraints, determine the change in its magnitude. Will there be any change in the mass and location of the other masses ?
20 marks · directive: Determine
The core of a good answer
Taking the masses at 0°, 120° and 240° in planes −50, 0 and +50 mm, the couple and force polygons need m·r = 10 kg·mm in each balancing plane: 0·0143 kg (14·3 g) at 0° in the plane beyond mass 3 and 0·0143 kg at 240° in the plane beyond mass 1; moving one to 50 mm radius makes it 0·2 kg at the same angle, with no change to the other.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Balancing of several masses rotating in different planes (dynamic balancing). Take one balancing plane as the reference plane to eliminate its unknown, close the couple polygon (Σmrl = 0) to find the other balancing mass, then close the force polygon (Σmr = 0) for the first. Only the product m·r is fixed, which answers part (ii).
Answer outline
Introduction
Let mass 1 (r = 20 mm) be at 0° in plane −50 mm, mass 2 (r = 30 mm) at 120° in plane 0, mass 3 (r = 20 mm) at 240° in plane +50 mm (x along the shaft from the middle eccentric). Balancing planes L at −100 mm and R at +100 mm, radius 700 mm (as printed).
Step 1: Table (reference plane L)
- m·r: 20, 30, 20 kg·mm at 0°, 120°, 240°
- Distances from L: 50, 100, 150 mm
- m·r·l: 1000, 3000, 3000 kg·mm² at 0°, 120°, 240°
Step 2: Couple polygon
- Σ(mrl) of given masses: x = 1000 + 3000(cos 120° + cos 240°) = −2000; y = 3000(sin 120° + sin 240°) = 0
- m_R × 700 × 200 must equal 2000 kg·mm² at 0°
- m_R = 2000/140000 = 0·01429 kg = 14·3 g at 0°
Step 3: Force polygon
- Σ(mr) of given masses: x = 20 − 15 − 10 = −5; y = 25·98 − 17·32 = 8·66
- Add m_R r_R = 10 at 0°: resultant (5, 8·66), magnitude 10 kg·mm at 60°
- m_L × 700 = 10 at 60° + 180° = 240°, so m_L = 0·01429 kg = 14·3 g at 240°
Step 4: Shift to 50 mm radius (ii)
- Balance requires only m·r = 10 kg·mm for that mass
- New mass = 10/50 = 0·2 kg, 14 times larger (change +0·186 kg), same angular position and plane
- The other balancing mass is unchanged in magnitude, radius and angle, because neither Σmr nor Σmrl changes
Note on data
- 700 mm is a very large radius for 20 to 30 mm eccentrics; if 70 mm was intended, each balancing mass is 0·143 kg, angles unchanged
Conclusion
Balancing masses of 14·3 g each at 700 mm radius: one at 0° in plane R (+100 mm, beyond mass 3) and one at 240° in plane L (−100 mm, beyond mass 1), angles measured from mass 1. Check: Σmr = 0 and Σmrl = 0 to round-off. (Recomputed in Python.)
Examples and data to cite
- A static (single-plane) balancer can correct in one plane only, so masses lying in different planes need correction in two planes.
Facts to remember
- Balance of rotating masses: the net centrifugal force and the net moment of these forces must both be zero, i.e. Σmr = 0 and Σmrl = 0 (all masses share ω²).
- Taking a balancing plane as reference removes its unknown from the moment equation.
- Two balancing masses in two chosen planes give two vector equations, enough to satisfy both conditions.
- Only the product m·r of a balancing mass is fixed; mass and radius trade off inversely.