A firm chooses between two processes (X and Y) to manufacture a component. Process X has a fixed cost of ₹ 9,60,000/year with a variable cost of ₹ 55/unit. Process Y has a fixed cost of ₹ 15,00,000/year with a variable cost of ₹ 38/unit. The selling price is ₹ 110/unit.
(i) Calculate the break-even volume for each process independently.
(ii) Determine the cross-over point between Process X and Process Y.
(iii) If the firm forecasts demand of 35,000 units, compute the profit under each process and recommend a choice. What is the margin of safety (%) under the preferred process.
10 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
Break-even volumes are 17,455 units (X) and 20,833 units (Y); the two cost lines cross at 31,765 units; at 35,000 units X earns ₹ 9,65,000 and Y ₹ 10,20,000, so Y is preferred, with a margin of safety of 40·5%.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Cost-volume-profit analysis. Break-even Q = F/(p − v); the cross-over point equates the total costs of the two processes; above it the process with lower variable cost is cheaper. Margin of safety = (actual − break-even)/actual.
Answer outline
Introduction
Contribution per unit: X = 110 − 55 = ₹ 55; Y = 110 − 38 = ₹ 72.
Step 1: Break-even (i)
- Q_X = 9,60,000/55 = 17,454·5 ≈ 17,455 units
- Q_Y = 15,00,000/72 = 20,833·3 ≈ 20,834 units
Step 2: Cross-over (ii)
- 9,60,000 + 55Q = 15,00,000 + 38Q
- 17Q = 5,40,000, Q = 31,764·7 ≈ 31,765 units
- Below this X is cheaper; above it Y is cheaper
Step 3: Profit at 35,000 units (iii)
- X: 35,000 × 55 − 9,60,000 = ₹ 9,65,000
- Y: 35,000 × 72 − 15,00,000 = ₹ 10,20,000
- Recommend Y (₹ 55,000 more profit; 35,000 is above the cross-over)
Step 4: Margin of safety under Y
- MoS = (35,000 − 20,833·3)/35,000 = 40·5%
- (For X it would be 50·1%: X is less profitable but less risky if demand falls)
Conclusion
Y is the better choice at the forecast demand, with profit ₹ 10,20,000 and margin of safety 40·5%. Check: total costs at 35,000 are ₹ 28,85,000 (X) and ₹ 28,30,000 (Y), consistent with the profits. (Recomputed in Python.)
Examples and data to cite
- Choosing between a general-purpose machine (low fixed, high variable cost) and an automated line (high fixed, low variable cost) is a typical cross-over decision.
- Firms facing uncertain demand may weigh the higher margin of safety of the lower fixed-cost option.
Facts to remember
- Break-even quantity = Fixed cost/(Price − Variable cost per unit).
- Cross-over point: Q = (F_Y − F_X)/(v_X − v_Y).
- Profit = Q(p − v) − F.
- Margin of safety = (Budgeted or actual sales − Break-even sales), expressed as a percentage of budgeted sales.