During a heat transfer process, the entropy change of incompressible substances, such as water, can be determined from ΔS = mC_avg ln(T₂/T₁). Show that for thermal energy reservoirs, such as large lakes, this relation reduces to ΔS = Q/T.
10 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
For a reservoir the mass is so large that a finite Q changes its temperature only by ΔT = Q/(mC_avg) ≪ T₁; then ln(T₂/T₁) = ln(1 + ΔT/T₁) ≈ ΔT/T₁, so ΔS ≈ mC_avg ΔT/T₁ = Q/T.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A short derivation. Express the temperature change of the substance through the heat transferred, then use the series expansion of the logarithm and the defining property of a reservoir (its temperature stays practically constant).
Answer outline
Introduction
For an incompressible substance, dU = mC dT and δQ = mC dT, so dS = mC dT/T and, with constant C_avg, ΔS = mC_avg ln(T₂/T₁). Let Q be the heat received by the lake (negative if it loses heat).
Step 1: Temperature change of the lake
- Q = mC_avg(T₂ − T₁), so T₂ = T₁ + Q/(mC_avg)
- T₂/T₁ = 1 + Q/(mC_avgT₁)
Step 2: Reservoir limit
- A thermal energy reservoir has such a large heat capacity mC_avg that ε = Q/(mC_avgT₁) → 0
- ln(1 + ε) = ε − ε²/2 + ε³/3 − ... ≈ ε when ε ≪ 1
Step 3: Result
- ΔS = mC_avg ln(1 + ε) ≈ mC_avg × Q/(mC_avgT₁) = Q/T₁
- Since T₂ ≈ T₁ = T, ΔS = Q/T
Step 4: Alternative view
- dS = δQ/T with T constant integrates directly to ΔS = Q/T, the internally reversible isothermal case
Conclusion
For any body whose heat capacity is very large compared with Q/T, its temperature is effectively constant and ΔS = Q/T; this is why entropy change of a reservoir is always written this way in entropy generation balances.
Facts to remember
- Entropy change of an incompressible substance: ΔS = mC_avg ln(T₂/T₁).
- Clausius definition dS = δQ_rev/T.
- ln(1 + x) ≈ x for |x| ≪ 1.
- A thermal energy reservoir supplies or absorbs finite heat without a change in temperature.