Show that the entropy change across the normal shock in an adiabatic flow in a duct is given by ΔS = −R ln(P₀Y/P₀X).
10 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
Across an adiabatic normal shock T₀X = T₀Y; writing the entropy change between the two stagnation states (each having the same entropy as its static state) gives ΔS = Cₚ ln(T₀Y/T₀X) − R ln(P₀Y/P₀X) = −R ln(P₀Y/P₀X), and since ΔS > 0, P₀Y < P₀X.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A derivation from the Gibbs relation for an ideal gas plus the energy equation. The key ideas are that stagnation enthalpy is conserved across an adiabatic shock with no work, and that the reference stagnation state is reached isentropically so it carries the same entropy.
Answer outline
Introduction
Let X denote the state just upstream and Y just downstream of the shock. Assume perfect gas with constant Cₚ, steady adiabatic flow, no work, no area change across the thin shock.
Step 1: Entropy change for a perfect gas
- Tds = dh − v dP gives s_Y − s_X = Cₚ ln(T_Y/T_X) − R ln(P_Y/P_X)
Step 2: Use stagnation states
- The stagnation state of each section is reached by isentropic deceleration, so s₀X = s_X and s₀Y = s_Y
- Hence s_Y − s_X = Cₚ ln(T₀Y/T₀X) − R ln(P₀Y/P₀X)
Step 3: Energy equation
- Adiabatic, no work: h_X + V_X²/2 = h_Y + V_Y²/2, i.e. h₀X = h₀Y
- For a perfect gas T₀X = T₀Y, so ln(T₀Y/T₀X) = 0
Step 4: Result and meaning
- ΔS = s_Y − s_X = −R ln(P₀Y/P₀X)
- Second law: ΔS > 0, so P₀Y/P₀X < 1: stagnation pressure always falls across a shock
- Example: air at M_X = 2 gives P₀Y/P₀X = 0.7209 (from the normal shock total pressure relation) and ΔS = −287 ln 0.7209 = 93.9 J/kg-K
Conclusion
The stagnation pressure ratio is a direct measure of the entropy produced by the shock; it is also why only compressive (not expansion) normal shocks are possible.
Examples and data to cite
- From the normal shock total pressure ratio relation, P₀Y/P₀X = 0.7209 for M_X = 2 in air (γ = 1.4).
Facts to remember
- Gibbs relation for a perfect gas: Δs = Cₚ ln(T₂/T₁) − R ln(P₂/P₁).
- Stagnation temperature is constant across an adiabatic normal shock.
- Entropy increases across a shock; stagnation pressure decreases.
- Downstream of a normal shock the flow is subsonic.