Differentiate between Fanno and Rayleigh flows.
10 marks · directive: Differentiate
The core of a good answer
Fanno flow is adiabatic flow with friction in a constant-area duct (stagnation temperature constant, stagnation pressure falls), while Rayleigh flow is frictionless flow with heat transfer in a constant-area duct (stagnation temperature changes with heat added or removed, and stagnation pressure falls with heating); both drive the Mach number towards 1 and both choke at M = 1.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A comparison question. Set the two flows side by side on assumptions, governing equations, the conserved quantities, the effect on Mach number and properties, their curves on the h-s diagram and their practical uses. A small table or point-by-point list suits the directive.
Answer outline
Introduction
Both are one-dimensional, steady, compressible flows in a constant-area duct, so continuity (ρV = constant) and the state equation apply to both; they differ in which non-isentropic effect drives the flow.
Driving effect and assumptions
- Fanno: wall friction, no heat transfer (adiabatic), no work
- Rayleigh: heat transfer, no friction, no work
Conserved quantities
- Fanno: mass flow and stagnation enthalpy (T₀ constant); momentum changes because of wall friction
- Rayleigh: mass flow constant; T₀ changes with the heat added or removed, q = Cₚ(T₀₂ − T₀₁)
Behaviour of Mach number
- Fanno: friction always drives subsonic flow up towards M = 1 and supersonic flow down towards M = 1; maximum duct length L* chokes the flow
- Rayleigh: heating drives M towards 1 in both regimes; cooling drives it away from 1; heat addition beyond q* chokes the flow
h-s diagram
- Fanno line: locus of states with the same mass flow and stagnation enthalpy; maximum entropy at M = 1
- Rayleigh line: maximum entropy at M = 1; maximum enthalpy (static temperature) at M ≈ 0.845 for γ = 1.4 (= 1/√γ)
Property trends (Rayleigh, subsonic, heating)
- Stagnation pressure falls with heat addition (the Rayleigh effect)
- Static temperature rises up to M ≈ 0.845 and then falls between M = 0.845 and 1 although heat is still being added
Applications
- Fanno: constant-area sections downstream of nozzles, for example in blowdown supersonic wind tunnels
- Rayleigh: turbojet combustion chambers (roughly constant area, negligible fuel mass addition)
Conclusion
Both flows are bounded by the sonic point, where entropy reaches its maximum; the intersection of the Fanno and Rayleigh lines for the same mass flux gives the two states connected by a normal shock.
Examples and data to cite
- Fanno line and Rayleigh line intersections give the upstream and downstream states of a normal shock.
- Heating can thermally choke a Rayleigh flow at M = 1.
Facts to remember
- Fanno: adiabatic, frictional, constant area; T₀ constant.
- Rayleigh: frictionless, with heat transfer, constant area.
- Both reach maximum entropy at M = 1.
- Rayleigh line maximum static enthalpy at M ≈ 0.845 for γ = 1.4.