Consider an oil-to-oil double-pipe heat exchanger, whose flow arrangement is not known. The temperature measurements indicate that the cold oil enters at 18 °C and leaves at 50 °C, while the hot oil enters at 75 °C and leaves at 40 °C. Assuming the mass flow rates of both the oils to be identical, determine the effectiveness and flow configuration of this heat exchanger.
10 marks · directive: Determine
The core of a good answer
Q_max corresponds to the 57 °C inlet difference, so ε = (75 − 40)/(75 − 18) = 35/57 ≈ 0.61 (0.56 if based on the 32 °C cold-side rise); the cold oil leaves hotter (50 °C) than the hot oil leaves (40 °C), and ε exceeds the parallel-flow limit of 0.5 for equal capacity rates, so the exchanger must be counter-flow.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Effectiveness from its definition, then deduce the arrangement from the temperature cross and from the parallel-flow ceiling on ε. Note that the readings are not exactly balanced (35 °C drop against 32 °C rise), and say how this affects the value.
Answer outline
Introduction
T_h,in = 75 °C, T_h,out = 40 °C, T_c,in = 18 °C, T_c,out = 50 °C, equal mass flow rates of similar oils, so C_h ≈ C_c = C.
Step 1: Maximum possible heat transfer
- Q_max = C_min(T_h,in − T_c,in) = C × (75 − 18) = 57C
Step 2: Actual heat transfer and effectiveness
- Hot side: Q = C(75 − 40) = 35C, ε = 35/57 = 0.614
- Cold side: Q = C(50 − 18) = 32C, ε = 32/57 = 0.561
- The readings are not balanced. If no heat is lost, C_h × 35 = C_c × 32, so the hot oil has the smaller capacity rate and ε = 35/57 = 0.614 exactly; if the specific heats are taken as equal, the 3 °C mismatch is heat loss and the cold-side value 0.561 is the heat actually recovered. State the assumption
Step 3: Flow configuration
- In parallel flow both streams exit towards a common temperature, so T_c,out < T_h,out always
- Here T_c,out = 50 °C > T_h,out = 40 °C: a temperature cross, possible only in counter-flow
- Also, for C_r = 1 parallel flow has ε ≤ 0.5; the measured ε > 0.5 again rules it out
Step 4: Consistency check (counter-flow, C_r = 1)
- ε = NTU/(1 + NTU), so ε = 0.614 needs NTU ≈ 1.59
Conclusion
Effectiveness ≈ 0.61 (hot-side basis) and the flow arrangement is counter-flow. Recomputed in Python.
Facts to remember
- ε = Q/Q_max, Q_max = C_min(T_h,in − T_c,in).
- Parallel flow cannot give T_c,out > T_h,out.
- Parallel flow, C_r = 1: ε_max = 0.5.
- Counter-flow, C_r = 1: ε = NTU/(1 + NTU).