A horizontal insulated cylinder has a frictionless and adiabatic piston held against stops by an external force of 500 kN, as shown in the figure below. The cross-sectional area of the piston is 0.5 m², and the initial volume is 0.25 m³. Helium gas in the cylinder is at 200 kPa, 100 °C. A valve is now opened to a line through which helium is flowing at 1.2 MPa, 200 °C, and the helium flows in, until the cylinder pressure just balances the external force on the piston, at which point the valve is closed. Assume ambient at T₀ = 300 K; for helium, Cₚ = 5.193 kJ/kg-K, R = 2.0771 kJ/kg-K and Cᵥ = 3.116 kJ/kg-K :
[Figure, described in words: a vertical supply line on the left is joined through a valve to the left end wall of a horizontal cylinder containing helium; at the right end the piston rests against stops on the helium side, and the external force F_ext pushes it from the right, towards the helium.]
Determine :
(i) The final mass in the cylinder (in kg)
(ii) The final temperature in the cylinder (in K)
(iii) The total entropy generation (in kJ/K)
(iv) The irreversibility (in kJ)
20 marks · directive: Determine
The core of a good answer
The piston stays on the stops until P = 500/0.5 = 1000 kPa, so the cylinder fills at constant volume: m₁ = 0.0645 kg, and solving m₂CᵥT₂ − m₁CᵥT₁ = (m₂ − m₁)CₚT_i with m₂ = P₂V/(RT₂) gives T₂ ≈ 645 K and m₂ ≈ 0.187 kg; S_gen ≈ 0.210 kJ/K and the irreversibility T₀S_gen ≈ 63.1 kJ.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A transient (uniform-state, uniform-flow) charging problem. Recognise that no boundary work is done because the piston cannot move until the gas pressure equals F/A; then apply mass and energy balances to the control volume, the ideal gas law for the final state, the entropy balance for the adiabatic control volume, and the Gouy-Stodola relation I = T₀S_gen.
Answer outline
Introduction
Initial: P₁ = 200 kPa, T₁ = 373.15 K, V = 0.25 m³. Line: P_i = 1200 kPa, T_i = 473.15 K. Final: P₂ = F/A = 500/0.5 = 1000 kPa, V unchanged (piston just balances, no movement). Insulated: Q = 0; no work.
Step 1: Initial mass
- m₁ = P₁V/(RT₁) = 200 × 0.25/(2.0771 × 373.15) = 0.06451 kg
Step 2: Energy balance
- m₂u₂ − m₁u₁ = m_i h_i with m_i = m₂ − m₁
- m₂CᵥT₂ − m₁CᵥT₁ = (m₂ − m₁)CₚT_i
- Substitute m₂ = P₂V/(RT₂): P₂VCᵥ/R − m₁CᵥT₁ = (P₂V/(RT₂) − m₁)CₚT_i
Step 3: (i) and (ii) Final state
- P₂V/R = 1000 × 0.25/2.0771 = 120.36 kg-K
- T₂ = 120.36 × 5.193 × 473.15/(120.36 × 3.116 − 0.06451 × 3.116 × 373.15 + 0.06451 × 5.193 × 473.15) = 644.9 K
- m₂ = 120.36/644.9 = 0.1866 kg; helium admitted m_i = 0.1221 kg
- Check: m₂CᵥT₂ − m₁CᵥT₁ = 300.0 kJ = m_ih_i
Step 4: (iii) Entropy generation
- S_gen = m₂s₂ − m₁s₁ − m_is_i (adiabatic)
- = m₂[Cₚ ln(T₂/T_i) − R ln(P₂/P_i)] − m₁[Cₚ ln(T₁/T_i) − R ln(P₁/P_i)]
- = 0.1866[5.193 ln(644.9/473.15) − 2.0771 ln(1000/1200)] − 0.06451[5.193 ln(373.15/473.15) − 2.0771 ln(200/1200)]
- = 0.1866 × 1.9873 − 0.06451 × 2.4887 = 0.2103 kJ/K
Step 5: (iv) Irreversibility
- I = T₀S_gen = 300 × 0.2103 = 63.1 kJ
Conclusion
Final mass ≈ 0.187 kg, final temperature ≈ 645 K, S_gen ≈ 0.210 kJ/K, irreversibility ≈ 63 kJ. The temperature rises above the line temperature because the flow work of the entering gas is converted into internal energy. Recomputed in Python.
Examples and data to cite
- Charging an evacuated rigid tank from a line gives T₂ = γT_line; here the initial gas and the lower final pressure keep T₂ (645 K) below γT_i = 789 K.
Facts to remember
- Uniform-state uniform-flow energy balance: m₂u₂ − m₁u₁ = m_ih_i + Q − W.
- Ideal gas: u = CᵥT, h = CₚT, PV = mRT.
- Δs = Cₚ ln(T₂/T₁) − R ln(P₂/P₁).
- Gouy-Stodola theorem: I = T₀S_gen.