Consider two black surfaces A₁ and A₂ as shown in the figure below. Define the term ‘radiation shape factors’. Also, find a general expression for the energy exchange between these surfaces when they are maintained at different temperatures T₁ and T₂, respectively. If both the surfaces are at the same temperature, find out the reciprocity relationship between them :
[Figure, described in words: two black plane surfaces drawn as tilted rectangles, A₁ at temperature T₁ (lower left) and A₂ at temperature T₂ (upper right); on each a pair of crossing lines marks a point, and the two points are joined by a straight line of length r.]
10 marks · directive: Define
The core of a good answer
The shape factor F₁₂ is the fraction of radiation leaving A₁ that reaches A₂ directly, F₁₂ = (1/A₁)∫∫ cos θ₁ cos θ₂ dA₁dA₂/(πr²); for black surfaces the net exchange is Q₁₂ = A₁F₁₂σ(T₁⁴ − T₂⁴), and with T₁ = T₂ the net exchange must be zero, giving the reciprocity relation A₁F₁₂ = A₂F₂₁.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A derivation question. Define the shape (view) factor, derive it from the radiation leaving an elemental area using intensity and solid angle, write the net exchange between black surfaces, and use the equal-temperature (equilibrium) argument for reciprocity.
Answer outline
Introduction
Black surfaces emit diffusely with E_b = σT⁴ and intensity I_b = E_b/π. Let θ₁ and θ₂ be the angles between the line r and the normals of dA₁ and dA₂.
Definition
- Radiation shape factor F₁₂ (view or configuration factor): the fraction of the radiant energy leaving surface 1 that is intercepted directly by surface 2
- It depends only on geometry (size, orientation, distance), not on temperature, for diffuse surfaces
Elemental exchange
- Solid angle of dA₂ seen from dA₁: dω = dA₂ cos θ₂/r²
- Energy from dA₁ reaching dA₂: dQ₁→₂ = I_b1 cos θ₁ dA₁ dω = E_b1 cos θ₁ cos θ₂ dA₁dA₂/(πr²)
- Total from A₁ to A₂: Q₁→₂ = E_b1 ∫∫ cos θ₁ cos θ₂ dA₁dA₂/(πr²)
Shape factor expressions
- Total leaving A₁ = A₁E_b1, so F₁₂ = (1/A₁)∫∫ cos θ₁ cos θ₂ dA₁dA₂/(πr²)
- Similarly F₂₁ = (1/A₂)∫∫ cos θ₁ cos θ₂ dA₁dA₂/(πr²)
Net exchange
- Q₁→₂ = A₁F₁₂σT₁⁴ and Q₂→₁ = A₂F₂₁σT₂⁴
- Q₁₂(net) = A₁F₁₂σT₁⁴ − A₂F₂₁σT₂⁴
Reciprocity
- If T₁ = T₂ the surfaces are in thermal equilibrium, so Q₁₂(net) = 0
- Then A₁F₁₂ = A₂F₂₁ (also visible from the symmetric double integral)
- Since it is purely geometric, it holds at any temperatures, so Q₁₂ = A₁F₁₂σ(T₁⁴ − T₂⁴) = A₂F₂₁σ(T₁⁴ − T₂⁴)
Conclusion
The shape factor carries all the geometry; for black surfaces the net exchange is A₁F₁₂σ(T₁⁴ − T₂⁴), and reciprocity A₁F₁₂ = A₂F₂₁ follows from zero net exchange at equal temperatures.
Examples and data to cite
- For a small convex body inside a large enclosure, F₁₂ = 1, so Q = A₁σ(T₁⁴ − T₂⁴).
- For two infinite parallel plates F₁₂ = F₂₁ = 1.
Facts to remember
- F₁₂ = (1/A₁)∫∫ cos θ₁ cos θ₂ dA₁dA₂/(πr²).
- Reciprocity: A₁F₁₂ = A₂F₂₁.
- Summation rule for an enclosure: Σⱼ Fᵢⱼ = 1.
- Stefan-Boltzmann law: E_b = σT⁴, σ = 5.670 × 10⁻⁸ W/m²K⁴.