“The COP of a simple vapour absorption refrigeration system is lower than the COP of a simple vapour compression refrigeration system under identical temperature conditions.” Is this statement correct thermodynamically? Justify your answer.
10 marks · directive: Justify
The core of a good answer
Yes: the ideal absorption COP is (1 − T₀/T_G) × T_E/(T₀ − T_E), the Carnot refrigerator COP multiplied by a heat-engine efficiency that is always below 1, so it is always lower than the ideal vapour compression COP T_E/(T₀ − T_E) between the same evaporator and ambient temperatures; but the comparison is between heat input and work input, which differ in thermodynamic quality, so a low absorption COP does not mean poorer use of primary energy.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Evaluate the statement with second-law reasoning. Derive the maximum COP of an absorption system as a combination of a Carnot engine and a Carnot refrigerator, compare it with the vapour compression limit, and then qualify the comparison by the different forms of energy input.
Answer outline
Introduction
Absorption system: heat Q_G at generator temperature T_G, refrigeration Q_E at T_E, heat rejected at ambient T₀; pump work negligible. Compression system: work W, refrigeration at T_E, rejection at T₀.
Ideal absorption COP
- Treat it as a reversible engine between T_G and T₀ driving a reversible refrigerator between T_E and T₀
- Engine: W = Q_G(1 − T₀/T_G); refrigerator: Q_E = W × T_E/(T₀ − T_E)
- COP_abs,max = Q_E/Q_G = (1 − T₀/T_G) × T_E/(T₀ − T_E)
Ideal compression COP
- COP_VC,max = T_E/(T₀ − T_E)
- Since (1 − T₀/T_G) < 1 for any finite T_G, COP_abs,max < COP_VC,max
Illustration
- T_G = 100 °C, T₀ = 30 °C, T_E = −10 °C: Carnot refrigerator COP = 6.58; ideal absorption COP = 0.188 × 6.58 = 1.23
Qualification
- COP of absorption is based on low-grade heat; that of compression on high-grade work (electricity)
- Absorption is attractive when waste heat, solar heat or district heat is available; double and triple effect machines can raise the COP above 1
Conclusion
The statement is thermodynamically correct: under identical temperatures the absorption COP is always lower, by the factor of the Carnot engine efficiency of its generator heat. The two COPs are not directly comparable as measures of merit, because heat is a lower grade of energy than work.
Examples and data to cite
- Absorption refrigerators can run on solar energy, burning fuels, factory waste heat or district heating.
- The Platen-Munters design (1922) adds hydrogen to the ammonia-water system so it runs at one total pressure without a pump.
Facts to remember
- Carnot refrigerator COP = T_E/(T₀ − T_E).
- Ideal absorption COP = (1 − T₀/T_G) × T_E/(T₀ − T_E).
- Absorption COP = Q_E/(Q_G + W_pump).
- Common pairs: NH₃-H₂O and H₂O-LiBr.