Pratidin
2026 · Mechanical Engineering Optional Paper II · 20 marksMainsQuestion 7b

An R717 simple saturation cycle refrigerator operates at 40 °C condenser and −16 °C evaporator temperatures. Determine COP and power per TR. If a liquid-vapour regenerative heat exchanger is installed in the system, with the suction vapour at 15 °C, what will be the effect on COP and power per TR?
Assume specific heat of vapour at condenser temperature as 3.1 kJ/kg-K, when no heat exchanger is used, and 2.9 kJ/kg-K, when heat exchanger is used.
The properties of R717 are given in the table below :
Temperature (°C) | Enthalpy (kJ/kg): Liquid (h_f), Vapour (h_g) | Entropy (kJ/kg-K): Liquid (s_f), Vapour (s_g)
−16 | 126.73, 1442.60 | 0.72511, 5.8420
40 | 390.59, 1490.42 | 1.64377, 5.1558
Draw the P-h diagram also. The specific heat of vapour corresponding to evaporator temperature may be assumed as 2.38 kJ/kg-K.

20 marks · directive: Determine

Answer

The core of a good answer

Simple cycle: discharge at 117.6 °C, h₂ = 1730.9 kJ/kg, refrigerating effect 1052.0 kJ/kg, work 288.3 kJ/kg, COP = 3.65 and 0.964 kW/TR; with the regenerative heat exchanger: suction at 15 °C (h = 1516.4 kJ/kg), discharge 162.4 °C, refrigerating effect 1125.8 kJ/kg, work 329.1 kJ/kg, COP = 3.42 and 1.028 kW/TR, so for ammonia the heat exchanger lowers COP by about 6% and raises power per TR.

An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work

What the question asks

A vapour compression cycle calculation with superheat. Find the discharge state from s = constant using the superheated vapour specific heat at condenser pressure, compute COP and kW per TR, then repeat with suction superheated to 15 °C and liquid subcooled by the heat exchanger energy balance.

Answer outline

Introduction

Simple saturation cycle: 1 dry saturated vapour at −16 °C, 2 superheated at condenser pressure, 3 saturated liquid at 40 °C, 4 after throttling (h₄ = h₃). 1 TR = 3.516853 kW. T in K: −16 °C = 257.15 K, 40 °C = 313.15 K, 15 °C = 288.15 K.

Step 1: Discharge state, simple cycle

Step 2: COP and power per TR, simple cycle

Step 3: With liquid-vapour heat exchanger

Step 4: COP and power per TR with heat exchanger

Step 5: P-h diagram

Conclusion

COP falls from 3.65 to 3.42 (about 6%) and power per TR rises from 0.964 to 1.028 kW; the gain in refrigerating effect is outweighed by the extra compressor work and the much higher discharge temperature, so for this ammonia cycle the regenerative heat exchanger does not pay. Recomputed in Python.

Facts

Facts to remember

Sources used for the explanation

Write a timed answer in the app