Describe any two methods to measure cardiac output. Explain the role of ‘Frank-Starling law’ in cardiac contraction.
10 marks · directive: Describe; Explain
The core of a good answer
Cardiac output (heart rate x stroke volume, about 5 L/min at rest in a healthy 70 kg adult) can be measured by the Fick principle (oxygen consumption divided by the arteriovenous oxygen difference) or by indicator dilution or thermodilution (Stewart-Hamilton equation), among others; the Frank-Starling law states that stroke volume rises with the volume of blood in the ventricles at the end of diastole, because stretch brings sarcomeres towards the optimal length, increases troponin sensitivity to Ca2+ and Ca2+ release, which lets the heart match output to venous return and keeps the two ventricles in balance.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Each half is 5 marks. For the methods, give principle, formula, procedure and limitations of two methods. For Frank-Starling, state the law, draw the ventricular function curve, give the cellular mechanism and the physiological significance.
Answer outline
Introduction
Cardiac output (CO) is the volume of blood pumped by each ventricle per minute: CO = heart rate x stroke volume; at rest it averages about 5 L/min in a healthy 70 kg adult.
Method 1: Fick principle
- Principle: the amount of a substance taken up by an organ per minute equals blood flow x arteriovenous concentration difference.
- Formula: CO = O2 consumption (mL/min) / (arterial O2 content minus mixed venous O2 content).
- Procedure: O2 consumption by spirometry; arterial sample from a peripheral artery; mixed venous sample from the pulmonary artery by catheter.
- Considered the most accurate method, but invasive and needs time for sample analysis.
Method 2: Indicator dilution and thermodilution
- A dye such as indocyanine green is rapidly injected into the right atrium, and its concentration is recorded downstream.
- CO is calculated from the area of the concentration curve using the Stewart-Hamilton equation.
- Thermodilution uses a pulmonary artery catheter; its use is in decline because studies suggest it does not improve patient outcomes.
- Non-invasive alternatives: Doppler echocardiography (aortic valve area x velocity-time integral x heart rate) and velocity-encoded MRI.
Frank-Starling law
- Statement: within physiological limits, the force of contraction and stroke volume increase as end-diastolic volume (preload) increases.
- Mechanism: maximal force is generated at an initial sarcomere length of about 2.2 micrometres; stretch increases troponin sensitivity to Ca2+, increases Ca2+ release from the sarcoplasmic reticulum and decreases the distance between thin and thick filaments so more cross-bridges form.
- Significance: matches output to venous return without depending on external regulation; keeps left and right ventricular outputs equal; explains the more forceful contraction after an extrasystole.
- Clinical: diastolic dysfunction is associated with reduced compliance, or increased stiffness, of the ventricle wall.
Conclusion
Fick and dilution methods measure what the heart delivers, and the Frank-Starling law explains how the heart adjusts that delivery beat by beat.
Examples and data to cite
- Otto Frank published his experiments on frog hearts in 1895; Ernest Starling experimented on intact mammalian hearts, such as those of dogs.
Facts to remember
- Cardiac output at rest averages about 5 L/min.
- Fick principle: CO = O2 consumption / arteriovenous O2 difference.
- Indicator dilution uses the Stewart-Hamilton equation.
- Maximal force is generated at an initial sarcomere length of about 2.2 micrometres.