Describe the pathogenesis of secondary tuberculosis. Enumerate five microscopic features of tuberculosis in AIDS.
10 marks · directive: Describe; Enumerate
The core of a good answer
Secondary (post-primary) tuberculosis arises mostly by reactivation of a latent focus when immunity weakens, and sometimes by reinfection; disease favours the apical posterior segments of the upper lobes, where granulomas of epithelioid histiocytes and giant cells undergo caseous necrosis, erode into airways and form cavities in which bacilli proliferate; in people with HIV the risk of active disease is much higher, cavitation is rare when immunosuppression is severe, lower lobe disease with adenopathy and effusion is seen, and more than half of cases are extrapulmonary.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Five marks for each half. The pathogenesis needs the sequence from latent infection to reactivation, the immune basis, the apical localisation, caseation and cavitation. The second half asks for five microscopic features of tuberculosis in AIDS; a list of those features could not be confirmed from the sources opened for this page, so it is not given here, and only the confirmed differences in tuberculosis with HIV are listed.
Answer outline
Introduction
Primary tuberculosis forms a Ghon focus with draining nodes, which can calcify and become visible on a chest X-ray (Ranke complex). Secondary tuberculosis is active disease after an earlier infection.
Pathogenesis of secondary tuberculosis
- Source: reactivation of a latent focus is the most common mechanism; reinfection is possible with a large inoculum or when a person is significantly immunocompromised.
- Trigger: weakening immunity; without HIV about 5 to 15 percent of latently infected people develop active disease in their lifetime, while HIV coinfection raises the risk of reactivation to about 10 percent per year.
- Site: dissemination within the lung favours the apical posterior segments, attributed among other factors to regional differences in oxygen tension.
- Immune response: macrophages, epithelioid cells, lymphocytes and fibroblasts gather into a granuloma with a peripheral rim of epithelioid histiocytes and multinucleated giant cells; Langhans giant cells are not specific for tuberculosis.
- Caseous necrosis forms in the centre of granulomas; Mycobacterium tuberculosis survives inside macrophages by blocking maturation of the phagosome and its fusion with the lysosome.
- Cavitation: the caseating granuloma erodes into an airway and forms a cavity within which bacilli proliferate (seen in 20 to 45 percent of adult cases; rare in young children and the severely immunocompromised); cavities connected to airways release live bacteria when coughed up.
- Spread: endobronchial spread from cavities, and through the bloodstream to seed many tiny tubercles (miliary or disseminated tuberculosis); healing leaves scars.
Tuberculosis with HIV: confirmed differences
- People with HIV are much more susceptible to active tuberculosis.
- Cavitation is rare in severely immunocompromised patients.
- Immunocompromised patients can show lower lobe disease with adenopathy and pleural effusion, unlike the upper lobe cavitary pattern of immunocompetent hosts.
- More than 50 percent of cases in people with HIV are extrapulmonary.
- Necrotising granulomatous inflammation is the hallmark of tuberculosis, but non-necrotising granulomas can also be present; a definitive diagnosis needs identification of the organism by culture.
Conclusion
Secondary tuberculosis is a disease of host immunity as much as of the bacillus, which is why its pattern changes when HIV weakens the immune response.
Examples and data to cite
- People coinfected with HIV have about a 30 percent chance of developing active disease, and their reactivation risk rises to about 10 percent per year.
- Disseminated (miliary) tuberculosis has a fatality of about 30 percent even with treatment.
Facts to remember
- Reactivation of a latent focus is the most common mechanism leading to active tuberculosis.
- Cavitation is seen in 20 to 45 percent of adult cases of post-primary tuberculosis.
- Necrotising granulomatous inflammation is the hallmark of tuberculosis; Langhans giant cells are not specific to it.
- Extrapulmonary tuberculosis occurs in more than 50 percent of cases among people with HIV.
- Immunocompromised patients can show lower lobe disease with adenopathy and pleural effusion.