Write a brief note on ‘atypical drowning’.
5 marks · directive: Write a note
The core of a good answer
Atypical drowning refers to deaths in water without the typical picture of water inhalation: dry drowning, in which laryngospasm keeps water out of the lungs until cardiac arrest (about 7 to 10 percent of cases, a term now discredited clinically); cold shock and cold-induced arrhythmias on sudden immersion, which can kill even strong swimmers; shallow water blackout after hyperventilation; and so-called secondary drowning, whose delayed form has not been confirmed in the medical literature; froth at the mouth and the diatom test then need careful interpretation.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Define the term by contrast with typical drowning, describe each type and its mechanism, and state the medicolegal difficulty and tests such as the diatom test.
Answer outline
Introduction
Drowning is the process of experiencing respiratory impairment from submersion or immersion in liquid (WHO, 2005); the definition does not imply death. In freshly drowned bodies large amounts of froth are present around the mouth and nostrils.
Types of atypical drowning
- Dry drowning: about 7 to 10 percent of people maintain the laryngeal seal until cardiac arrest, so little water enters the lungs; as a medical condition the term has never had an accepted definition and is discredited.
- Cold shock on sudden immersion in cold water: uncontrolled rapid breathing and gasping cause water inhalation; of those who die after plunging into freezing seas, around 20 percent die within 2 minutes from cold shock.
- Secondary drowning: described as a physiological response to foreign matter in the lungs, but no case of death hours or days later from drowning alone has been identified in the medical literature.
- Shallow water blackout: hyperventilation before swimming or diving lowers blood carbon dioxide, so the person loses consciousness under water.
- Cold submersion can induce cardiac arrhythmias, sometimes causing strong swimmers to drown.
Medicolegal importance
- Diatom test: diatoms should normally never be in human tissue unless water was aspirated, but they occur in soil and air, so samples may be contaminated, and their absence does not rule out drowning.
Conclusion
Atypical drowning is death associated with water without the typical drowning picture, and its recognition calls for careful use of circumstances and tests such as the diatom test.
Examples and data to cite
- WHO estimates around 300,000 drowning deaths a year worldwide, 92 percent in low and middle income countries.
Facts to remember
- WHO definition: drowning is the process of experiencing respiratory impairment from submersion or immersion in liquid.
- In about 7 to 10 percent of drownings laryngospasm keeps water out of the lungs (dry drowning).
- Froth around the mouth and nostrils is present in freshly drowned bodies.
- Whether a person drowns in fresh or salt water makes no difference to respiratory management or outcome.