What is identification? Describe in brief the primary and secondary characteristics of identification. Which is the surest test for identification of an individual? Why?
10 marks · directive: Describe
The core of a good answer
Identification is establishing who a person is, living or dead, by applying forensic science and technology; Interpol names friction ridge analysis (fingerprints), forensic odontology and DNA analysis as the three primary methods of human identification, while other features serve as secondary, supporting characteristics; fingerprints are traditionally the surest test because their ridge patterns form by about the 15th week of fetal life, do not change over time, last until decomposition and differ even between identical twins, who share their DNA.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Marks 3+4+3: define identification and its medicolegal need, list primary and secondary characteristics with examples, and name the surest test with the scientific reasons. Forensic medicine textbooks give their own lists of primary and secondary characteristics; those lists could not be confirmed from the sources opened for this page, so only the Interpol primary methods are set out, and the secondary characteristics are not listed here.
Answer outline
Introduction
Identification is needed for the living and the dead, for example after mass disasters. Forensic identification is the application of forensic science and technology to identify specific objects or persons.
Primary characteristics
- Interpol names three primary methods of human identification: friction ridge analysis (fingerprints), forensic odontology (dental comparison) and DNA analysis.
Secondary characteristics
- Secondary characteristics support an identification made by the primary methods; their textbook list is not set out here (see demand).
Surest test and why
- Fingerprints (dactylography): ridge features form at about the 15th week of fetal development and remain until decomposition begins after death; patterns are unique to each individual and do not change over time; even identical twins, who share their DNA, do not have identical fingerprints.
- Francis Galton calculated the chance of a false match at about 1 in 64 billion.
- The Henry classification, credited mainly to Azizul Haque and Hem Chandra Bose of a Kolkata bureau set up in 1897, allows systematic search.
- Fingerprint matching is among the most widely used and most reliable biometric techniques, but the validity of forensic fingerprint evidence has been challenged by academics, judges and the media; DNA cannot separate identical twins.
Conclusion
Identification rests on primary methods that individualise and secondary features that corroborate; fingerprints remain the classic surest test because they are unique and permanent.
Examples and data to cite
- Disaster victim identification techniques include fingerprinting, dental records and DNA profiling.
- Loops make up about 60 to 65 percent of fingerprints, whorls 30 to 35 percent and arches about 5 percent.
Facts to remember
- Fingerprint ridges form at about the 15th week of fetal development and remain until decomposition begins.
- Identical twins do not have identical fingerprints.
- Interpol lists friction ridge analysis, forensic odontology and DNA analysis as the three primary methods of identification.
- The Henry classification was developed by Azizul Haque and Hem Chandra Bose.