Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(b) Explain the distinction between Intuitive knowledge and Demonstrative knowledge as propounded by Locke.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
For Locke knowledge is the perception of the agreement or disagreement of ideas: in intuitive knowledge the mind perceives this agreement immediately, while in demonstrative knowledge it perceives it only through intervening ideas (proofs), each step of which must itself be intuitive; demonstration is therefore certain but not so clear and bright as intuition, and is preceded by doubt.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the distinction between Locke's first two degrees of knowledge in Book IV of the Essay. The answer should define knowledge for Locke, set out the marks of each degree with examples, and note sensitive knowledge as the third degree for contrast.
Answer outline
Introduction
In An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, Book IV, Locke defines knowledge as the perception of the agreement or disagreement of any of our ideas, and distinguishes degrees of knowledge by the way that agreement is perceived (IV.ii).
Intuitive knowledge (IV.ii.1)
- The mind perceives the agreement or disagreement of two ideas immediately, by themselves, without any other idea intervening.
- It is irresistible and certain, and leaves no room for hesitation.
Demonstrative knowledge (IV.ii.2 to 7)
- The mind cannot bring two ideas together directly, so it uses intervening ideas, called proofs; this is demonstration.
- Every step in a demonstration is intuitive, yet the whole is not altogether so clear and bright, nor the assent so ready, as in intuition.
- Before a demonstration there is doubt about the agreement or disagreement of the ideas (IV.ii.5).
- Demonstration is not confined to mathematics: Locke holds that God's existence (IV.x) and moral claims (IV.iii.18) can be demonstrated.
Contrast and third degree
- Intuition is immediate; demonstration is mediate, needs intervening proofs and is preceded by doubt.
- Sensitive knowledge (IV.ii.14), of the particular existence of finite things outside us, goes beyond mere probability but falls short of the other two degrees.
Conclusion
Locke's ranking makes intuition the foundation and demonstration a chain of intuitions, a rationalist structure inside an empiricist theory of the origin of ideas.
Examples and data to cite
- Locke's demonstration of God's existence (Essay IV.x): since some real being exists and bare nothing cannot produce any real being, something has existed from eternity, an eternal, most powerful and most knowing being.
- Locke says we have an intuitive knowledge of our own existence (IV.ix.3).
Facts to remember
- Essay IV.i.2: knowledge is the perception of the agreement or disagreement of ideas.
- Locke lists four sorts of agreement: identity or diversity, relation, coexistence or necessary connection, and real existence (IV.i.3 to 7).
- Three degrees of knowledge: intuitive, demonstrative and sensitive (IV.ii).