Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(c) Explain Hegel’s idea that the concept of the Absolute as being is the concept of the Absolute as becoming as a process of self-development.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
For Hegel the Absolute cannot be grasped as a fixed, simple being: pure being, thought through, shows itself to depend on its opposite, nothing, and the category that reconciles them is becoming; so the Absolute is a self-developing process that unfolds its own determinations up to the Absolute Idea.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the logic behind Hegel's claim that Absolute-as-being is really Absolute-as-becoming. The answer should use the opening triad of the Science of Logic, the dialectical method (Aufhebung) and the development of the categories up to the Absolute Idea and on into nature and spirit.
Answer outline
Introduction
Being without further determination is the most abstract way to think the Absolute. Hegel argues that this concept, when thought through, does not stay fixed but turns into becoming.
Being, nothing, becoming
- Science of Logic (1812 to 1816) begins with pure being, which seems immediate and simple.
- Thought through, being shows itself to depend on its opposite, nothing; becoming is the category that reconciles the two.
- So the most abstract definition of the Absolute, as being, already contains the movement of becoming.
Self-development
- Dialectic: each determination passes into its opposite, and the third term of a triad sublates (aufheben: negates but preserves) the first two; the categories develop up to the Absolute Idea, with which the Science of Logic ends.
- Hegel's logic is not only a science of the form of thought but of actual content: the forms of pure thinking are the forms of being.
- The Encyclopaedia (1817) carries the development from the Logic through the Philosophy of Nature to the Philosophy of Spirit.
Significance
- Being and process, logic and history, are not opposed; the Absolute is the whole movement, not a static ground behind it.
- Critics: Schelling attacked Hegel's rationalism, an attack that passed into Kierkegaard's existentialism, and Marx turned Hegel's ideas into a materialist theory of history.
Conclusion
The Absolute as being is an abstraction; thought concretely it is becoming, a process of self-development in which it realises and knows itself.
Examples and data to cite
- The opening triad of the Science of Logic: Being, Nothing, Becoming.
- The Encyclopaedia of the Philosophical Sciences (1817, revised 1827 and 1830) divides into Logic, Philosophy of Nature and Philosophy of Spirit, tracing this development.
Facts to remember
- Phenomenology of Spirit appeared in 1807.
- The Science of Logic appeared in three books in 1812, 1813 and 1816.
- Hegel's Absolute Idea is the final category of the Logic.