Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(d) Compare and contrast the notion of entelechy as presented in Aristotle’s and Leibniz’s philosophy.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Compare and contrast
The core of a good answer
Both use entelechy for an internal principle of actuality and activity, but for Aristotle it is the actuality or form of a natural body (the soul is the first actuality of a natural organic body), whereas for Leibniz entelechies are the simple substances themselves, monads that are the source of their own activity, and the soul is the dominant entelechy of a living body.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The directive asks for both likeness and difference. Define the term in each philosopher, show what they share (inner activity, the definition of soul), then show where they part (form of a natural body versus simple substance).
Answer outline
Introduction
Entelecheia is one of Aristotle's words for actuality, contrasted with potentiality. Leibniz revived the term for his simple substances and for the primitive active force he set against the Cartesian view that the essence of matter is extension.
Aristotle
- In the Metaphysics (Theta) entelecheia and energeia name actuality, opposed to dunamis (potentiality); actuality is prior to potentiality in account, in time and in substance.
- In De Anima II.1 the soul is the first actuality of a natural organic body (412b5 to 6), the form of a natural body which has life potentially (412a20 to 21).
- The soul is not separable from the body (413a3 to 5); body and soul relate as wax and its shape.
Leibniz
- Monadology (1714) section 18: all simple substances or created monads might be called entelechies.
- Section 19 reserves the name soul for monads whose perception is more distinct and accompanied by memory.
- Section 70: each living body has a dominant entelechy, which in an animal is the soul.
- Primitive active force is nothing but the first entelechy and corresponds to the soul or substantial form of the scholastics; against Descartes, extension is a repetition or distribution of more basic forces.
Comparison
- Common: both make entelechy an inner principle of activity and both use it to define the soul.
- Difference: Aristotle's entelechy is the form of a natural body and is not separable from it; Leibniz calls the simple substances themselves entelechies, and treats extension as derived from force.
Conclusion
Leibniz keeps Aristotle's teleological core but turns the actuality of a body into the substance underlying bodies.
Examples and data to cite
- Leibniz: primitive active force 'is nothing but the first entelechy' and corresponds to the soul or substantial form of the scholastics.
- Leibniz's Monadology was written in 1714 and translated into English by Robert Latta (1898).
Facts to remember
- Metaphysics Theta treats actuality (energeia, entelecheia) and potentiality (dunamis).
- Monadology section 18 calls all created monads entelechies.
- Monadology section 70: each living body has a dominant entelechy, which in an animal is the soul.