Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(e) “I can prove now, for instance, that two human hands exist.” How does Moore use this illustration to prove the existence of an external world? Critically discuss.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Critically discuss
The core of a good answer
In Proof of an External World (1939) Moore holds up his hands: here is one hand, here is another, so at least two external objects exist, so there is an external world; he claims the proof is rigorous because its premises differ from the conclusion, are known to be true, and entail it, but critics such as Crispin Wright argue that it is subtly circular and so begs the question against the sceptic.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must reconstruct the argument and Moore's conditions for a good proof, explain his common-sense strategy, and then evaluate it, covering both sympathetic and critical readings.
Answer outline
Introduction
Moore's 1939 British Academy lecture takes up a task Kant had set himself, a proof of the existence of external objects, and offers a deliberately simple proof.
The proof
- Premise 1: Here is one hand (gesturing with the right hand).
- Premise 2: Here is another (gesturing with the left).
- Conclusion: there are at least two external objects, hence an external world exists.
- Moore's three conditions for a rigorous proof: the premises are different from the conclusion, the premises are known, and the conclusion follows from them; he claims all three are met.
Moore's strategy
- In A Defence of Common Sense (1925) he argued that the sceptic cannot give reasons for his premises that are stronger than our reasons for common-sense claims such as that one has hands.
- Moore says he knew that there was a hand in the place indicated and that doubting it would be absurd; his aim was to prove the existence of external objects, not to prove his knowledge of them.
- External objects are things whose existence does not depend on our experience, so if two hands exist an external world exists.
Criticisms
- Begging the question: Crispin Wright (2002) argues that the proof is subtly circular, because warrant for 'here is a hand' fails to transmit to the conclusion that there is an external world.
- Wittgenstein's On Certainty, notes written up to his death in 1951 and published in 1969, responds to Moore and treats such propositions as hinge propositions.
- James Pryor (2004) holds that perceptual experience gives immediate, fallible justification, so the proof is transmissive and its oddness is dialectical, not epistemic.
Conclusion
Moore's proof shows that common-sense certainty can outweigh philosophical doubt, but as a refutation of scepticism it is widely judged to presuppose what it sets out to prove.
Examples and data to cite
- G. E. Moore, Proof of an External World, British Academy lecture, 1939.
- Wittgenstein, On Certainty (1969), his last writings, much influenced by Moore.
Facts to remember
- Moore's A Defence of Common Sense was published in 1925.
- Moore's three requirements: premises different from conclusion, premises known, conclusion follows.