How does Hume account for ideas of reason? How does Kant respond to Hume’s views in this regard? Critically discuss.
15 marks · directive: Critically discuss
The core of a good answer
Hume traces every idea to a prior impression and finds that the idea of necessary connection has no external impression behind it: it is copied from an internal feeling of expectation produced by custom; Kant accepts that such concepts cannot come from experience but argues they are a priori concepts of the understanding that are conditions of the possibility of experience, valid for appearances only, while reason's ideas of soul, world and God yield no knowledge.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must set out Hume's empiricist account (copy principle, the fork, the analysis of causation) and Kant's reply (synthetic a priori, categories, transcendental deduction, Ideas of Reason), and then evaluate the exchange.
Answer outline
Introduction
Hume's Treatise (1739 to 1740) and Enquiry (1748) test the claims of reason by asking from which impression each idea is derived. Kant's answer is the synthetic a priori of the Critique of Pure Reason (1781, 1787).
Hume
- Copy principle: all simple ideas are less lively copies of simple impressions.
- Hume's fork: relations of ideas, known independently of experience and necessary, and matters of fact, which depend on experience and are contingent.
- Causation: no impression of necessary connection is found in the objects; after constant conjunction the mind feels a determination to pass from cause to effect, and the idea of necessity is copied from this internal impression; inference from experience rests on custom or habit, not reason.
- The self is a bundle or succession of associated perceptions, a view Hume himself doubted in the Appendix to the Treatise.
Kant's response
- Critique of Pure Reason (1781, 1787): there are synthetic a priori judgements, neither analytic nor learnt from experience.
- Cause and substance are categories, pure concepts of the understanding; the transcendental deduction argues they 'must be recognized as a priori conditions of the possibility of experiences' (A93 to 94/B126).
- The price: the categories hold for possible appearances only; things in themselves remain unknown.
- The Transcendental Dialectic criticises rational psychology, cosmology and theology, which use reason's ideas of soul, world and God beyond experience; such ideas have a regulative, not a constitutive, use.
Evaluation
- Kant restores necessity without returning to dogmatic metaphysics, but at the cost of limiting knowledge to appearances: 'I had to deny knowledge in order to make room for faith' (Bxxx).
- Critics ask whether the deduction proves necessity or only our need to think in these terms.
Conclusion
Hume made reason's central ideas products of habit; Kant made them conditions of experience, saving their necessity while confining them to the phenomenal world.
Examples and data to cite
- Hume: inductive inference rests on custom or habit, a propensity to repeat an operation without reasoning (EHU 5.5).
- Kant: we can cognize of things a priori only what we ourselves put into them (Bxviii).
Facts to remember
- Hume's Treatise appeared in 1739 (Books 1 and 2) and 1740 (Book 3); the Enquiry concerning Human Understanding in 1748, first as Philosophical Essays concerning Human Understanding.
- Kant's Critique of Pure Reason: first edition 1781, second 1787.