Explain Heidegger’s conception of authenticity and inauthenticity as modes of Dasein’s being.
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
In Being and Time (1927) Dasein can be authentically a self, owning its existence in the face of its finitude (Eigentlichkeit), or lose itself in the anonymous norms of the 'anyone' or 'they' (das Man); falling into the they is not a bad ontical property but an existential structure of Dasein's everyday being, and authenticity is reached through anxiety, being-towards-death, conscience and resoluteness.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should define Dasein and its two modes, describe everyday inauthentic existence, explain how anxiety, being-towards-death, conscience and resoluteness lead to authenticity, and note Heidegger's insistence that falling is a structure of being, not a moral grade.
Answer outline
Introduction
Heidegger's term Dasein picks us out insofar as we have an understanding of being. Being and Time first analyses Dasein in its average everydayness (Division One) and then turns to authenticity (Division Two).
Two modes
- Dasein can be authentically a self in primordial individualization (SZ 324), or be lived by the publicness of the anyone.
- Falling is an ontologico-existential structure; Heidegger protests against taking it as a bad and deplorable ontical property (SZ 176).
Inauthentic everydayness
- Das Man, the anyone or 'the they': the public, averaged norms by which one does what one does.
- Idle talk is the possibility of understanding everything without previously making the thing one's own (SZ 169); inauthentic life is lived by the common-sense ambiguity of publicness (SZ 299).
- There is a constant temptation towards falling (SZ 177).
Becoming authentic
- In anxiety things show up as of no consequence (SZ 186), loosening the hold of everyday significance.
- Death is the possibility of the absolute impossibility of Dasein (SZ 250); anticipating it individualizes Dasein down to itself (SZ 263).
- The call of conscience asserts nothing and gives no information (SZ 273); it summons Dasein to be the 'guilty' that it is (SZ 287).
- Choosing to choose to be a self is resoluteness (SZ 270); authentic existence is anticipatory resoluteness, and Dasein can historize (SZ 385 ff.).
Conclusion
Authenticity is not escape from the world but a way of owning the same everyday possibilities in the light of one's finitude.
Examples and data to cite
- Heidegger, Being and Time (1927): Division One analyses Dasein's everydayness; Division Two turns to death, conscience, guilt and resoluteness; the planned Division Three never appeared.
Facts to remember
- Being and Time was published in 1927.
- German terms: Eigentlichkeit (authenticity), das Man (the they or the anyone), Entschlossenheit (resoluteness).
- Heidegger protests against taking falling as a bad and deplorable ontical property (SZ 176).