Can words be viewed as the ideas in the mind of the person who uses them? Answer with reference to the philosophy of later Wittgenstein.
15 marks · directive: Answer with reference
The core of a good answer
The later Wittgenstein rejects the view, often attributed to Locke, that words signify ideas in the speaker's mind: the meaning of a word is its use in the language (PI 43), within language-games and forms of life, and the private language argument shows that a sign correlated only with a private inner item could have no criterion of correct use and so no meaning.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should state the ideational theory, then use Philosophical Investigations (1953): meaning as use, language-games and forms of life, rule-following, and the private language argument (the sensation diary and the newspaper analogy) to answer 'No'.
Answer outline
Introduction
On a view often attributed to Locke, speakers translate their inner ideas into sounds and hearers translate the sounds back into ideas; words would then stand for ideas in the mind of the person who uses them.
Meaning as use
- PI 43: the meaning of a word is its use in the language.
- PI 23: speaking a language is part of an activity, or of a form of life; agreement in language is agreement in form of life (PI 241).
- PI 1 opens with Augustine's picture of the essence of human language, in which words name objects, and goes on to criticise it.
Rule-following
- PI 201: no course of action could be determined by a rule, since any action can be made out to accord with it.
- Hence meaning requires public criteria of correctness.
Private language argument
- PI 243: in a private language the words would refer to what only the speaker can know, his immediate private sensations.
- PI 258 sensation diary: if I write S whenever I have a certain sensation, whatever is going to seem correct to me is correct.
- PI 265: checking one memory against another is like buying several copies of the morning paper to assure oneself that what it said was true.
Assessment
- Whether the argument shows that sensations cannot be talked about at all is disputed among commentators.
- Kripke (1982) reads the rule-following remarks as a sceptical paradox about meaning with a community solution; whether this is Wittgenstein's view remains disputed.
Conclusion
Words are not labels for ideas in a private mind; they get their meaning from public use within shared forms of life.
Examples and data to cite
- Philosophical Investigations was published posthumously in 1953.
- Saul Kripke, Wittgenstein on Rules and Private Language (1982).
Facts to remember
- PI 243 defines a private language.
- PI 258 is the sensation diary (S) example.
- The view that words stand for ideas in the speaker's mind is often attributed to Locke.