“Wittgenstein’s difficulty about not being able to say anything within a given language about the structure of that language can be met by the idea of a hierarchy of languages.” Do you agree with this statement? Give reasons and justifications for your answer.
20 marks · directive: Do you agree
The core of a good answer
Russell, in his introduction to the Tractatus, suggested that what cannot be said about a language's structure within that language can be said in a second language dealing with the structure of the first, and so on without limit; this meets the difficulty technically, as Tarski's metalanguages later showed, but not on Wittgenstein's own terms, because the logical form that any language must share with reality would be presupposed at every level and so could still only be shown.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The statement is Russell's proposal. The answer should explain Wittgenstein's saying/showing distinction, set out the hierarchy solution and its later development, and take a reasoned position.
Answer outline
Introduction
Tractatus 4.12 to 4.121: propositions can represent the whole of reality but cannot represent the logical form they must share with it; they mirror it. What can be shown cannot be said, and the closing remarks treat the book's own propositions as nonsense to be thrown away like a ladder.
The hierarchy proposal
- Russell's introduction suggested that every language has a structure about which nothing can be said in that language, but there may be another language dealing with the structure of the first, and the hierarchy may have no limit.
- Tarski's 1933 monograph on truth concludes that the truth definition for a language must be given in a metalanguage essentially stronger than it, since otherwise the liar paradox arises.
- Carnap's Logical Syntax of Language (1934) treats the syntax of a language formally, by the kinds and order of its symbols, without reference to meaning.
Reasons to agree
- Metalogic is a working discipline: we do state truths about the structure of formal languages.
- The hierarchy removes the self-reference that produces paradox, and removes the need to call philosophy nonsense.
Reasons to disagree
- For Wittgenstein the logical form at issue is not that of one notation but that of any language capable of representing the world; a metalanguage can describe the syntax of an object language only by itself having that form, which it cannot state.
- The regress never reaches the top: the last language in any series is unsayable about itself.
- The later Wittgenstein answered the difficulty differently: the Investigations (1953) describe language-games from within, rather than adding levels.
Conclusion
The hierarchy of languages answers a technical question about formal systems, but it does not dissolve Wittgenstein's point about the form common to language and reality; it relocates it.
Examples and data to cite
- Russell's Introduction to the 1922 English edition of the Tractatus.
- Tarski's 1933 Polish monograph on the concept of truth in the languages of the deductive sciences.
Facts to remember
- Tractatus 4.121: a proposition cannot represent logical form; it mirrors it.
- The Tractatus was first published in German in 1921 and in English in 1922 with Russell's introduction.