Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(a) According to Nyāya view of inference (Anumāna), what are the characteristics that ascertain the validity of inferential sign (Hetu)? Discuss.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
In Nyāya a hetu (middle term) is valid when it is present in the subject (pakṣa), present in similar instances (sapakṣa), absent from dissimilar instances (vipakṣa), not contradicted by an established truth (abādhitatva) and not countered by evidence for the opposite (asatpratipakṣitva); behind these lies invariable concomitance (vyāpti) with what is to be proved (sādhya), and each failed mark yields a pseudo-reason (hetvābhāsa).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must place the hetu within anumāna, list and explain the five marks with the stock example of smoke and fire, link them to vyāpti and to the fallacies, and note any qualification (such as purely positive or purely negative inferences).
Answer outline
Introduction
In anumāna, from the sign (hetu or liṅga) seen in the subject and its known pervasion by the property to be proved, one infers something beyond the range of the senses: the hill has fire, because it has smoke.
Five marks of a valid hetu
- Presence in the pakṣa: the hetu must belong to the subject (smoke is on the hill).
- Presence in sapakṣa, cases where the sādhya is known to be present (a kitchen).
- Absence from vipakṣa, cases where the sādhya is known to be absent.
- Abādhitatva: the conclusion must not be contradicted by an established truth, such as perception.
- Asatpratipakṣitva: there must be no counter-evidence for the opposite thesis.
Vyāpti and the fallacies
- The second and third marks secure vyāpti: Uddyotakara combined Dignāga's second and third tests into a single requirement, knowledge of pervasion.
- Pervasion may take repeated experience to recognise; Nyāya appeals to extraordinary perception for it, and tarka tests a doubtful pervasion against more basic commitments.
- Pseudo-reasons are classed in five kinds: deviation (savyabhicāra), contradiction (viruddha), unestablishment (asiddha), rebuttal (bādhita) and counterbalancing (satpratipakṣa).
- Each corresponds to a failed mark: asiddha to presence in the pakṣa, savyabhicāra and viruddha to concomitance, bādhita to abādhitatva, satpratipakṣa to asatpratipakṣitva.
Qualifications
- Nyāya also recognises wholly positive and wholly negative inferences (described by Uddyotakara), where no dissimilar or no similar instances exist, so not all five marks can apply.
- Dignāga's trairūpya (three marks) covers the first three; the Nyāya list adds the last two.
Conclusion
The five marks are checks that the hetu is really pervaded by the sādhya and that nothing stronger defeats the inference.
Examples and data to cite
- Stock inference: the hill has fire, because it has smoke; wherever there is smoke there is fire, as in a kitchen.
- Five-membered syllogism: pratijñā, hetu, udāharaṇa, upanaya, nigamana.
Facts to remember
- The Nyāya Sūtra is attributed to Akṣapāda Gautama.
- Dignāga's trairūpya gives three conditions of a good reason.