Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(b) How does the Buddhist theory of momentariness problematize the issue of human action and responsibility? Critically discuss.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Critically discuss
The core of a good answer
If, as the doctrine of momentariness holds, phenomena last only a moment, there is no enduring agent who acts and later reaps the result, so it becomes unclear how karma, rebirth and responsibility work; the Buddhist reply is that a causally connected continuum (santāna) of momentary events, carrying the traces of past actions, secures continuity of karma without a permanent self.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should state the doctrine and its ground, set out how it creates the problem of agency and responsibility, give the Buddhist reply, and evaluate.
Answer outline
Introduction
Momentariness (kṣaṇikavāda) develops the teaching of impermanence: phenomena are a succession of discrete moments; the Sarvāstivāda held that all physical and mental phenomena are momentary.
The problem
- Action needs an agent who intends, acts and is answerable later; if there is no enduring agent and actions are only transient events, who is blamed or rewarded?
- Karmic results often arise long after, and unlike, their causes; causal theories struggled to explain this.
- Memory, recognition and the pursuit of liberation also seem to presuppose an enduring subject.
Buddhist reply
- There is no substantial self (anātman), but there is a continuum (santāna) of causally connected momentary events.
- Milindapañha: Nāgasena's name is a conventional designation with no permanent self behind it, as 'chariot' is a term for arranged parts.
- Karma passes as seeds (bīja) within the series (Sautrāntika), the precursor of the Yogācāra store consciousness (ālayavijñāna), which holds the seeds and sustains karmic continuity.
- Karma is created when the mind actively responds to its object, and that response bears future results within the same series.
Evaluation
- The reply explains continuity but critics say it cannot explain ownership: why this later moment is answerable for that earlier act.
- Defenders answer that ethics needs causal continuity, not a soul.
Conclusion
Momentariness forces Buddhism to ground responsibility in causal continuity rather than identity; whether that suffices remains the central debate.
Examples and data to cite
- Milindapañha: the name Nāgasena, like 'chariot', is a conventional designation.
- Sautrāntika theory of seeds (bīja) as the precursor of ālayavijñāna.
Facts to remember
- Theravāda treats only mental phenomena as momentary; Sarvāstivāda treats all phenomena as momentary.
- Santāna is the continuum of causally connected momentary events.