Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(c) Is Puruṣa one or many? Explain and examine the Sāṁkhya position in this context.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain and examine
The core of a good answer
Sāṁkhya holds that puruṣas are many: Sāṁkhyakārikā 18 argues from the fact that beings are born and die separately, that each has its own instruments of cognition and action, and that the guṇas affect each being differently; critics reply that all these differences belong to body and mind (prakṛti), not to pure, featureless consciousness.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the Sāṁkhya position and a critical examination of it. Explain what puruṣa is, give the arguments of Kārikā 18, then evaluate.
Answer outline
Introduction
In Īśvarakṛṣṇa's Sāṁkhyakārikā reality has two principles: prakṛti, composed of the three guṇas (sattva, rajas, tamas), and puruṣa, the conscious witness, separate, neutral and inactive (Kārikā 19).
Arguments for plurality (Kārikā 18)
- Beings are born and die separately; if there were one puruṣa, the birth or death of one would be that of all.
- Each being has its own instruments of cognition and action.
- The guṇas operate in each being differently; one is more sāttvika, another rājasa or tāmasa.
Examination
- Each argument points to differences of body, senses and intellect, which Sāṁkhya itself assigns to prakṛti; puruṣa is described as all-pervasive, motionless and unchangeable.
- Pure consciousness without attributes cannot be told apart from another such consciousness, so plurality seems unfounded (an identity of indiscernibles argument).
- A monist reading takes one Self appearing as many through the limitations of body and mind.
- In Sāṁkhya's favour: it explains individual experience and individual liberation without making bondage illusory.
Conclusion
The plurality of puruṣa is a reasonable inference from the plurality of experience, but it sits uneasily with the doctrine that puruṣa has no distinguishing features.
Examples and data to cite
- Britannica: Sāṁkhya posits an infinite number of similar but separate puruṣas, none superior to any other.
Facts to remember
- Sāṁkhyakārikā 18 gives the reasons for the plurality of puruṣas.
- The Sāṁkhyakārikā is attributed to Īśvarakṛṣṇa; Britannica dates him to about the third century CE, while other scholars place the text in the Gupta period.