Bring out the main points of contestation between Naiyāyikas and Prabhākara Mīmāṁsakas with reference to knowledge through words (Śābdabodha).
15 marks · directive: Bring out
The core of a good answer
Naiyāyikas and Prābhākaras disagree on how verbal knowledge arises: for Nyāya testimony is the statement of a trustworthy expert, the speaker's intention (tātparya) matters, the Veda is authoritative because God is its author and validity is extrinsic; for Prabhākara words convey their meanings only as connected with other words (anvitābhidhāna), the core of Vedic language is what is to be done (kārya), the Veda is authorless, the speaker's intention is irrelevant and knowledge is valid by itself.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should identify the main points of dispute (sentence meaning, the role of the speaker's intention, the word-meaning relation, the authority of the Veda, validity), giving each side's argument.
Answer outline
Introduction
Śābdabodha is the knowledge produced by understanding a sentence. Both schools accept śabda as a pramāṇa, but they explain it differently.
Sentence meaning
- Prabhākara (anvitābhidhānavāda): words do not designate meanings in isolation; word meaning arises through connection with other words and is understood from the sentence context.
- Nyāya treats the speaker's intention (tātparya) as epistemically relevant; for Prabhākara the speaker's intention is irrelevant.
Main import of language
- Prabhākara: Vedic injunctions are prescriptive, about kārya, what is to be done.
- Nyāya: sentences about existing things are equally a source of knowledge.
Word and meaning
- Nyāya: words have a representational power that must have a cause, and that cause is God.
- Mīmāṁsā: the relation between Vedic words and their meanings is primordial (Jaimini's fifth sūtra).
Authority and validity
- Nyāya: testimony is the true statement of an expert (āpta); Udayana argues that the infallible Vedas must have an author, God; validity is extrinsic (parataḥ prāmāṇya).
- Prabhākara: the Veda is authorless (apauruṣeya), its words not spoken by anyone originally; everyday testimonial knowledge, like all knowledge, wears its truth on its sleeve (svataḥ prāmāṇya).
Conclusion
The dispute turns on whether meaning is built up from isolated words or is relational and action-centred from the start.
Examples and data to cite
- Udayana's argument that the Vedas must have an author, God.
- Prabhākara Mīmāṁsā accepts five pramāṇas; the Bhāṭṭa school adds a sixth, anupalabdhi.
Facts to remember
- Prabhākara is dated variously from the sixth to the eighth century CE.
- Mīmāṁsā holds svataḥ prāmāṇya, the intrinsic validity of knowledge.