Explain the meaning of seven steps of judgement (Saptabhaṅgīnaya) and its application in Jaina’s Syādvāda for advocating a philosophy of non-absolutism (Anekāntavāda).
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Saptabhaṅgī is the Jaina scheme of seven conditional predications, each prefixed by syāt (in some respect): it is, it is not, it is and is not, it is indescribable, and three combinations of these with indescribability; it expresses anekāntavāda, the view that reality has infinite aspects, so that no absolute single assertion can capture it.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain the seven predications with an example, the role of syāt and of the standpoints (naya), show how they support non-absolutism, and note the main objections.
Answer outline
Introduction
Anekāntavāda holds that reality is many-sided, so any absolute assertion is false. Syādvāda is its logical expression, and later Jaina texts systematised it as the sevenfold scheme (saptabhaṅgīnaya), first formulated by Mallavādin (fifth or sixth century CE).
The seven predications
- Syād asti: in some respect it is.
- Syād nāsti: in some respect it is not.
- Syād asti nāsti: in some respect it is and it is not (successively).
- Syād avaktavya: in some respect it is indescribable (both at once).
- Syād asti avaktavya; syād nāsti avaktavya; syād asti nāsti avaktavya.
Application
- A jar exists as regards its own substance, place, time and being, and does not exist as regards those of other things: it is earthen, not wooden; in the room, not on the terrace.
- Syāt does not mean doubt but a conditional yes: each statement is true relative to a standpoint.
- Nayas (standpoints) and the parable of the blind men and the elephant show that one-sided views are partial truths.
Objections and replies
- Śaṅkara (Brahmasūtrabhāṣya 2.2.33 to 36) argues that contradictory attributes such as being and non-being cannot belong to one thing at once, and that an indefinite doctrine gives no basis for action.
- Buddhist logicians Dignāga and Dharmakīrti held that it violates the law of non-contradiction; Dharmakīrti asked why, then, one does not eat a camel instead of curd.
- Jaina reply: all propositions are context-dependent, so attributes predicated in different respects do not contradict.
- P. C. Mahalanobis related the predications to multi-valued and probabilistic reasoning.
Conclusion
Saptabhaṅgī turns intellectual non-violence into a method: every judgement is true from a standpoint, and none is the whole truth.
Examples and data to cite
- The parable of the blind men and the elephant.
- The jar that is earthen but not wooden, in the room but not on the terrace.
Facts to remember
- Syāt is usually glossed as in some respect or perhaps.
- Anekāntavāda means non-absolutism or many-sidedness.