Do you agree with Nimbārka’s explanation of the nature of God, Souls and Matter? Justify your answer.
15 marks · directive: Do you agree; Justify
The core of a good answer
Nimbārka's svābhāvika bhedābheda holds that souls (cit) and the non-sentient world (acit) are both really different from and non-different from God (Brahman, Kṛṣṇa), as rays from the sun or sparks from fire, being wholly dependent on Him; one can largely agree, since it keeps the world and souls real and makes the relation natural rather than due to limiting conditions, while noting the difficulty of holding difference and non-difference together without contradiction.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Set out Nimbārka's account of the three realities and their relation, then take a reasoned position with arguments for and against.
Answer outline
Introduction
Nimbārka (dated variously; many historians place him in the twelfth or thirteenth century, others in the seventh), author of the Vedānta Pārijāta Saurabha on the Brahma Sūtra and the Daśaślokī, taught Dvaitādvaita, natural difference-in-identity.
God, souls and matter
- Brahman, framed as Kṛṣṇa together with Rādhā, is the independent reality (svatantra) and both the efficient and material cause of the universe.
- Cit: souls are infinite in number, atomic, eternal, of the nature of knowledge and knowers with knowledge as an attribute; they retain their individuality.
- Acit: the non-sentient world is real, a real manifestation of Brahman's power, not an illusion.
- Souls and world are dependent (paratantra) on Brahman for existence and activity; the relation is natural (svābhāvika), not due to limiting conditions as in Bhāskara's aupādhika bhedābheda.
Reasons to agree
- It reconciles Upaniṣadic texts of identity and of difference without explaining either away.
- The world and souls are real, so moral effort and devotion (bhakti) have meaning.
- Unlike strict dualism, it preserves God's immanence.
Reasons for reservation
- Difference and non-difference in the same respect look contradictory.
- If the world is non-different from God, its imperfections seem to touch God; the school answers that Brahman is like the sun, unaffected when its rays touch impure things.
- Analogies such as sun and rays explain dependence but not identity.
Conclusion
Nimbārka's account is persuasive as a devotional theology of dependence, but as metaphysics it must specify the respects in which difference and identity hold.
Examples and data to cite
- Analogies used in the school: the sun and its rays, fire and its sparks.
- Bhāskara's aupādhika bhedābheda attributes difference to limiting conditions; Nimbārka's makes it natural.
Facts to remember
- Nimbārka's school is called Dvaitādvaita or svābhāvika bhedābheda.
- His works include the Vedānta Pārijāta Saurabha and the Daśaślokī.