Present an account of Upamāna as an instrument of knowledge (Pramāṇa). How is Nyāya view of Upamāna different from Mīmāṁsā view? Discuss.
20 marks · directive: Present an account; Discuss
The core of a good answer
Upamāna is knowledge through comparison: in Nyāya it is restricted to learning the meaning of a word, as when one told that an unfamiliar animal is like a cow later sees such an animal and learns what the word for it denotes; Mīmāṁsā (and Vedānta) instead treat it as the pramāṇa for knowledge of similarity itself, a special object known through this special source.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Give the Nyāya account with its example, then set out the Mīmāṁsā account and the points of difference, and mention schools that do not accept upamāna as a separate pramāṇa.
Answer outline
Introduction
Upamāna is accepted as a separate pramāṇa by Nyāya, Mīmāṁsā and Advaita Vedānta; Cārvāka (perception only), Buddhists and Vaiśeṣika (perception and inference), and Sāṁkhya and Jainas (perception, inference and testimony) do not list it.
Nyāya view
- Analogy makes an object known by similarity with something already known.
- A traveller told that an unfamiliar animal looks like a cow, but differs in certain ways, can identify the animal later when he sees it.
- For Nyāya, analogy is restricted to a subject's learning the meaning of a word: the result is knowledge that this animal is what the word denotes.
- Nyāya holds that analogical cognition is its own kind, though it draws on other pramāṇas (perception of similarity, recollection of the statement).
Mīmāṁsā view
- Mīmāṁsā treats analogy as the capacity to apprehend similarity itself.
- Similarity is taken to be a special object known through this special source.
Differences
- Object: the word-referent relation (Nyāya) versus similarity (Mīmāṁsā).
- Role of testimony: in Nyāya the prior verbal description is part of the process.
Schools that do not accept it
- Cārvāka accepts only perception; Buddhists and Vaiśeṣika accept perception and inference; Sāṁkhya and Jainas accept perception, inference and testimony.
Conclusion
Both schools defend upamāna as irreducible, but Nyāya makes it a source of word meaning while Mīmāṁsā makes it the knowledge of similarity.
Examples and data to cite
- The animal like a cow: a person told of the likeness recognises the animal later and learns its name.
- Mīmāṁsā and Vedānta treat similarity as a special object of upamāna.
Facts to remember
- Nyāya accepts four pramāṇas: perception, inference, comparison and testimony.
- Prabhākara Mīmāṁsā accepts five pramāṇas and Bhāṭṭa Mīmāṁsā six.