Critically explain Rāmānuja’s conception of Brahman with special reference to the difficulties in explaining the relation of Brahman to Spirit (Cit) and Matter (Acit).
15 marks · directive: Critically explain
The core of a good answer
For Rāmānuja Brahman is the personal God (Nārāyaṇa with Śrī), possessing innumerable auspicious qualities and untouched by impure qualities, who is one but qualified by sentient and non-sentient beings (cit and acit), which are real, wholly dependent on Him and form His body and modes; the difficulties are whether the body's change and imperfection then touch Brahman, how dependent realities can be inseparable from Him, and whether the result is really non-dualism.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain Viśiṣṭādvaita's Brahman, the body-soul and substance-mode relations, creation as the passage from subtle to gross states, and then the specific difficulties, with the replies the tradition gives.
Answer outline
Introduction
Rāmānuja (traditionally 1017 to 1137; recent scholarship 1077 to 1157), in the Śrībhāṣya and Vedārthasaṅgraha, rejects Śaṅkara's attributeless Brahman and illusory world.
Brahman
- Brahman is a person comprising innumerable auspicious qualities; impure qualities do not touch Brahman.
- Cit and acit are completely dependent on Brahman; Brahman is their inner controller (antaryāmin), who governs all beings from within.
- Body-soul relation (śarīra-śarīri-bhāva): Brahman stands to all others as the soul stands to its body; also expressed as śeṣa and śeṣin.
- Individuals are modes (prakāra) of Brahman's body.
- With subtle cit and acit as its body Brahman is in the causal state; with expanded cit and acit it is in the effect state.
Difficulties
- Imperfection: if matter and souls are Brahman's body, their change and impurity seem to affect Brahman. The tradition's answer: impure qualities do not touch Brahman.
- Immutability: a Brahman that transforms is not changeless. Answer: it is the modes (souls and world) that evolve, while Brahman as the universal Self is unchanging and eternal.
- Relation: how souls can be integral parts of Brahman yet have their own existence needs explaining; critics doubt that the analogy of body and soul suffices.
- Unity: if souls are real and many, is Viśiṣṭādvaita a disguised pluralism? Rāmānuja defends a plurality of persons while affirming the substantial unity of all, the non-duality of the qualified whole.
Conclusion
Rāmānuja secures a real world and a personal God, but his solution rests on analogies whose limits critics have pressed.
Examples and data to cite
- Rāmānuja's critique of Advaita: ignorance presupposes a real individual who is ignorant, so individuals cannot be products of ignorance.
- The pair śeṣa and śeṣin (the dependent and that on which it depends) expresses the same relation.
Facts to remember
- Viśiṣṭādvaita is usually translated as qualified non-dualism.
- The Śrībhāṣya is Rāmānuja's commentary on the Brahma Sūtra.