Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Why does Rawls consider it necessary that the two principles of justice be applied in lexical order ? Explain.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Rawls ranks his principles lexically (equal basic liberty first, then fair equality of opportunity, then the difference principle) so that no gain in wealth or efficiency can ever justify a loss of basic liberty: liberty may be restricted only for the sake of liberty, which protects the self-respect and moral standing of free and equal persons.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the reason behind the ordering, not just a statement of the two principles. A good 150-word answer defines lexical (serial) order, states what it rules out (trade-offs between liberty and economic advantage) and gives Rawls's grounds for it, with the condition under which it applies.
Answer outline
Introduction
In A Theory of Justice (1971) John Rawls argued that parties in the original position, behind a veil of ignorance, would choose two principles of justice: equal basic liberties for all, and a second principle that permits social and economic inequalities only under fair equality of opportunity and to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged.
What lexical order means
- A lexical (serial) order is like alphabetical ordering: a principle must be fully satisfied before the next one comes into play, and a later principle cannot outweigh an earlier one however large its gain.
- The order is: first principle (equal basic liberty) before the second; within the second, fair equality of opportunity before the difference principle.
- Basic liberties can be restricted only for the sake of liberty: a less extensive liberty must strengthen the total system of liberty shared by all, and a less than equal liberty must be acceptable to those with the lesser liberty.
Why Rawls insists on it
- To block utilitarian trade-offs: without a strict ranking, a large enough gain in aggregate welfare could be used to justify denying some people's liberties, asking the less favoured to accept lower prospects for the sake of the higher expectations of others.
- Basic liberties secure the social bases of self-respect, which Rawls calls perhaps the most important primary good; parties in the original position would not gamble them for economic advantage.
- Under uncertainty behind the veil of ignorance, the parties choose cautiously (maximin reasoning) and protect what they cannot afford to lose.
Condition and criticism
- The priority holds under reasonably favourable social conditions; where conditions do not yet allow the basic liberties to be effectively enjoyed, Rawls allows restrictions only as far as needed to prepare for a time when they can be.
- H. L. A. Hart (1973) argued that Rawls had not adequately explained why the parties would adopt the basic liberties and their priority; in reply, in 'The Basic Liberties and Their Priority' (Tanner Lecture, 1981), Rawls restated the first principle as a right to a fully adequate scheme of equal basic liberties.
Conclusion
Lexical priority is how Rawls keeps the rights of each person from being sold for the welfare of all; it is the core of his anti-utilitarian theory of justice.
Examples and data to cite
- H. L. A. Hart, "Rawls on Liberty and Its Priority" (University of Chicago Law Review, 1973), a critique of the priority of liberty.
- Rawls, 'The Basic Liberties and Their Priority' (Tanner Lecture, 1981), revises the first principle to a fully adequate scheme of equal basic liberties.
Facts to remember
- A Theory of Justice was published in 1971 (revised edition 1999).
- The first principle has priority over the second; within the second, fair equality of opportunity has priority over the difference principle.
- Liberty can be restricted only for the sake of liberty.
- Rawls calls this ordering lexical (or serial) order; it works like alphabetical order, where an earlier letter settles the ranking whatever follows.