Pratidin
2026 · Philosophy Optional Paper II · 20 marksMainsQuestion 3a

Retributivism presents a deontological justification for capital punishment, whereas deterrence presents a consequential justification for it. Explain.

20 marks · directive: Explain

Answer

The core of a good answer

Retributivism justifies the death penalty backward looking, as the deserved response to a grave wrong whatever its effects (Kant), while deterrence justifies it forward looking, by the harm it prevents (Bentham); each has internal difficulties, and India's 'rarest of rare' doctrine mixes both.

An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work

What the question asks

Explain asks you to make clear why one view is deontological and the other consequentialist. Define the two moral frameworks, set out each justification of capital punishment with its classical source, note the main objections, and relate to Indian law.

Answer outline

Introduction

A deontological theory judges acts by duty and rightness in themselves; a consequentialist theory judges them by outcomes. Theories of punishment divide in the same way.

Retributivism (deontological)

Deterrence (consequentialist)

Objections

Indian law

Conclusion

The two theories answer different questions, why punishment is deserved and what it achieves; a defensible position must satisfy both desert and necessity, which is why many argue life imprisonment meets the aims of punishment without the irreversibility of death.

Examples and data to cite

Facts

Facts to remember

Sources used for the explanation

Write a timed answer in the app