Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Discuss Aquinas’ argument from the contingency of the world to prove the existence of God.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Aquinas's Third Way argues that since contingent things (which can be and not be) exist, and they cannot all be contingent, there must be a necessary being whose necessity is from itself, which all call God; the argument is powerful but faces objections of a possible fallacy in its key step, of the meaningfulness of 'necessary being' and of whether that being must be the God of theism.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Discuss asks you to state the argument clearly and weigh it. Give the premises in order, explain the key concepts, then the main criticisms and replies.
Answer outline
Introduction
Thomas Aquinas (1225 to 1274) gave five ways of proving God's existence in the Summa Theologiae, Part I, Question 2, Article 3. The Third Way is the argument from possibility and necessity (contingency).
The argument
- We find in nature things that are possible to be and not to be, since they are generated and corrupted.
- What can not be at some time is not; if everything could not be, then at one time there would have been nothing.
- If at one time nothing existed, nothing would exist now, since what does not exist begins only through something already existing; but things exist now.
- So not all beings are merely possible; there must be something necessary.
- Necessary beings either have their necessity caused by another or not; an infinite series is impossible, so there must be a being necessary of itself, which all men speak of as God.
Criticisms
- Quantifier shift: from 'each contingent thing fails to exist at some time' it does not follow that 'at some time all things failed to exist'; there may never be a time when no contingent being exists.
- Hume (Dialogues, 1779) held that once the parts are explained, the whole needs no further cause; Kant held that the cosmological argument depends on the ontological argument to identify its necessary being.
- Russell (1948) held that the universe is 'just there, and that's all'.
- Even if valid, it proves a necessary being, not necessarily a personal, good creator.
Defence
- Leibniz's principle of sufficient reason restates the argument without the time premise.
- Matter or the universe as a whole does not explain itself, so the question why there is something remains.
Conclusion
The Third Way captures a deep question about why anything exists at all; its formulation needs repair, but in Leibnizian form it remains one of the strongest cosmological arguments.
Examples and data to cite
- Russell (1948): the universe needs no explanation; it is 'just there, and that's all'.
- Leibniz, Monadology, section 32: the principle of sufficient reason.
Facts to remember
- Summa Theologiae I, q.2, a.3 gives the Five Ways.
- The Third Way is the argument from possibility and necessity.
- Aquinas lived 1225 to 1274.