Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
How does Paul Tillich’s idea of faith as ultimate concern address the relation between faith, doubt and reason ? Evaluate.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Evaluate
The core of a good answer
For Tillich faith is the state of being ultimately concerned; since it is an act of the whole person directed at the unconditional, it includes doubt as an element (the risk of faith) and, being expressed in symbols rather than literal claims, does not compete with reason; the view reconciles faith with doubt and science but may make faith so broad that it loses specific content.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Evaluate asks for an account and a judgement. Explain 'ultimate concern', then show how it reframes faith and doubt and faith and reason, and assess strengths and weaknesses.
Answer outline
Introduction
Paul Tillich (1886 to 1965), a German American Lutheran theologian, set out his view in Dynamics of Faith (1957). Faith is the state of being ultimately concerned, an act of the total personality.
Faith and doubt
- Ultimate concern involves risk, because faith may be directed upon a false ultimate (idolatry, for example making a nation or success ultimate).
- So doubt is not the opposite of faith: Tillich treats radical doubt as part of faith's seriousness, in which meaning is affirmed within meaninglessness.
- In The Courage to Be (1952) the ultimate source of courage is the 'God above God', who transcends the God of theism.
Faith and reason
- Religious language is symbolic: symbols participate in the reality they point to, so they are not literal hypotheses for reason to test.
- God is being itself, the ground of being, not a being among others, so faith does not make claims that compete with science or reason.
Evaluation
- Strength: makes room for honest doubt and avoids a war between religion and science.
- Weakness: almost any deep commitment counts as faith, so the concept may become too wide; one may ask whether 'being itself' can be an object of personal devotion.
- It is open to question whether symbolic language gives any truth claims at all.
Conclusion
Tillich's account dignifies doubt and frees faith from conflict with reason, at the cost of some determinacy in what faith affirms.
Examples and data to cite
- Dynamics of Faith, 1957.
- The Courage to Be, 1952: 'God above God'.
Facts to remember
- Tillich defines faith as the state of being ultimately concerned.
- Doubt is an element of faith in Tillich's account.
- Tillich lived 1886 to 1965.